Cdeleted

[Altarium]

Honestly most of the bears (except maybe Teddy) are just really creepy to me, like just look at Charlise or Beardo

 

[Hanif1807]

Chow, Spork, and Penny. There might be more though

 

[Jhine7]

Gotta go with Pietro.

 

[Lady Timpani]

Don't let this distract you from the fact that Aurora and Dotty's eyes glow red

Add Jacob to that list.

 

[N a t]

Beardo makes me uncomfortable

 

[Rasha]

Yes, Chow is horrifying, I would never have him on my island.
Creepy looking villagers I could think of are Roscoe, Rodeo (I love these two), Coco and Lucky

 

[Clock]

I don't have any creepy villagers on my island so far but, Jitters and Caesar creeps me out in my WW town, but Rasher did creep me out in NL.

 

[biksoka]

Diva and Rodeo

 

[AustinS]

I have a friend that is convinced that Marina is creepy due to her lack of facial movement and her mouth, I can't really see it though. For me the only villager that creeps me out at all is Pietro.

 

[victoriae350]

Pietro. I read the comment a few down (I'm just like :/). Sorry, but he reminds me of the clown from It. Animal version. Coco is a little freaky.

 

[Hsn97]

I love chow so much but he is hella creepy. He reminds be of a shaved panda XD

 

[jokk]

i second chow

 

[Hsn97]

But whilst we’re on the subject can we talk about Diva

 

[fairyring]

rasher nasty pig with a creepy face and a huge scar who is the color of old blood no ty

 

[starlightsong]

I feel like many creepy villagers are also cute, but I can't look past the creepy bit lol
Stitches is so cute but those eyes... aren't even eyes? ;-;
Lucky is cute but - is he dead? or is he just a dog with a lot of fractures? lol
Coco is cute but her being an empty shell is just weird to me
and any character with eyes like Jitter just creep me out
and oh god Chow looks so creepy

I know you probably weren’t genuinely asking but I looked up that exact question about Lucky once and I found out that according to nookipedia, his e-reader card profile is as follows:
“Lucky took luck into this own hands when he went on that fateful fishing trip last week. Between casting his rod too far, snagging his line on a rock, and losing his balance and falling overboard, Lucky's luck held true to form.”
So I think the idea is supposed to be, the fact that he isn’t dead is what makes him lucky, lol. Either that or his name is a joke about how extremely unlucky it was for that to happen.
Also I agree about Stitches and I’m glad to see someone who does lol! I always thought his eyes were unsettling and I only recently realized why: it’s because he resembles an old teddy bear but with Xes for eyes instead of buttons, and it makes it look like his eyes got torn off and only the stitches were left behind. So now whenever I look at him I just have to wonder if he can even see!

 

[Jared:3]

Apple is freaking creepy as heck not sure why people like her but those eyes are really scary I want her to stay far away from my island!

 

[charris114]

I have chow’s amiibo card, and I’ve put a sticky note on it because it gives me the creeps.

 

[Rosewater]

Lionel, Chops, Tammi

 

[Fridaynightcatlady]

Coco

 

[due]

There are plenty of ugly/creepy villagers out there, but did anybody ever mention Ruby or Carmen? Those.. those things are all of my nightmares put in to harmless rabbits.
I like Graham, but he is creepy. Not his looks, but his dialogue, though.
Is it weird to be in love with a tilapia?
I'm gonna go ahead and respect your boundaries by not copying you... for two weeks!
The princess-that's you- will have to wake the prince-that's me- with a kiss. On the lips.
With a kiss on the cheek?
he's a simp and a neckbeard