Mafia Bravely Default Mafia

[Pathetic]

u can't really get away w being lazy as a "vet" bc ppl will expect you to be pro-town i guess? that's kinda a weird psychology if u ask me. i'd expect a vet to be protown & very active .. so .. u can't rly go by unnoticed i guess thts just me

 

[Ashtot]

And because he serves up this 'I'm too tired' attitude in all his recent games and can justafiably get away with it being a veteran player on tbt, but he does this both when he's mafia and when he's not mafia, so him outright townclaiming should be taken with a grain of salt. That being said, I should also read you (problem/elise) and waffles since I know you well enough, along with BluRose, but really - what is Tom doing anyways? Calling other players lazy when he's even lazier than them.

Tom generally plays that way. He hates day 1 because there's not much you can do so he mostly just sits back. It's a play style choice and I don't think it necessarily means he's lazy. There are generally enough people discussing so he can still form thoughts and opinions without being actively vocal throughout the day. I don't think "he could be mafia" and him not being vocal on day 1 is enough for a vote on him. That's just my opinion though.

 

[Geoni]

I was really active in different parts of the forum last night (check my activity feed if you doubt me), and left this page open in a separate tab, refreshing it every once in a while to read the new posts.

Alright, I'll give you that. I do it all the time because my browser is constantly a tab explosion.

 

[Ashtot]

@ashtot whatever happened to your Capella vote
(jsyk i'm still reading into the game so i apologize if i mess up somewhere)

My vote on Cap wasn't going anywhere so I switched to Runeraider because he's semi inactive/doesn't care about the game.

Right now though I'm not sure about Sonrio. His reasoning is just really off but the only thing his actions could show is that he's desperate scum, but there's no way of knowing for sure.

 

[Geoni]

can still form thoughts and opinions without being actively vocal throughout the day.

Except he isn't doing this, which is why I find him problematic. Pretty sure he's self-aware about his day one personality the way Jeremy is about his.

 

[Ashtot]

Except he isn't doing this, which is why I find him problematic. Pretty sure he's self-aware about his day one personality the way Jeremy is about his.

Well we can't know what he's thinking. I mean there isn't much reason for him to be posting in the first place. The lynch options are obvious and narrowed down, it's typical day 1. I agree that that isn't necessarily the way you should play but I don't see it as extremely problematic.

 

[Pathetic]

er, isn't cap considered the same thing?
i mean, it's random lynching at this point. all of the inactives have the same reasoning (not caring about the game, less posting, lurking, etc.) it's all the same.

the only *strong* player lynches that are considered d1 are like.
- blu rose
- nikkinikki (?)
- tom
at the moment. i have no idea why you guys r being so like. hasty on tom. i know it's almost the end of the day but i think we have enough time left

- - - Post Merge - - -

where is pillow bunny, DarkOnyx and Capella? why only Rune?

 

[Ashtot]

er, isn't cap considered the same thing?
i mean, it's random lynching at this point. all of the inactives have the same reasoning (not caring about the game, less posting, lurking, etc.) it's all the same.

If you're referring to my vote: I was the only person to have voted for Cap, and since the day's almost over, it would be smarter for me to switch to a different inactive player that already had votes on them, because at the time I didn't want Sonrio to be lynched, and he had 3 votes.

the only *strong* player lynches that are considered d1 are like.
- blu rose
- nikkinikki (?)
- tom
at the moment. i have no idea why you guys r being so like. hasty on tom. i know it's almost the end of the day but i think we have enough time left

I agree that Tom shouldn't be lynched and the only reason I haven't considered the other inactives is because nobody has voted for them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

frig i messed up the quote my answer is in your quote problem

 

[Geoni]

Thing is, out of every tbt vet on the playerlist, Tom is the only one I've been mafia with, and recently I might add. I'm going to push on him if I notice something about him that seems familiar and there's a chance we can lynch scum, because who knows whether or not this is my last day and if he'll coast by if he's mafia without anyone calling him out on it. That being said, I won't call him a coaster yet because coasting accusations require more days than one, but it's definitely something you should watch Tom for.

 

[Pathetic]

if i remember tom usually claims blue as mafia. but that was quite a while ago so i don't know if that'll help or anything. it's just noted for me

unfortunately this day is probably going to end into a bandwagon (on rune? i am not watching the votes), as ashtot is doing at the moment

 

[Ashtot]

Thing is, out of every tbt vet on the playerlist, Tom is the only one I've been mafia with, and recently I might add. I'm going to push on him if I notice something about him that seems familiar and there's a chance we can lynch scum, because who knows whether or not this is my last day and if he'll coast by if he's mafia without anyone calling him out on it. That being said, I won't call him a coaster yet because coasting accusations require more days than one, but it's definitely something you should watch Tom for.

I completely agree. He should definitely watched, I just don't believe he's worth today's lynch.

 

[Pathetic]

i also agree. also has rune even posted anything at all yet?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I do enjoy claiming blue and making up roles as scum. B)

 

[Pathetic]

hi tommy ru mafia? who do u think is scum

 

[Geoni]

And just because somebody doesn't care about the game doesn't mean they're scum - if you're going to have that attitude day one, you might as well lynch somebody who hasn't said a thing at all like DarkOnyx or pillow bunny. But I mean, going after people for legitimate suspicions takes effort I guess. Personally, it's not rune's not caring that raises flags for me, but the genuine defense mode they put up in response to what was said to them.

 

[Pathetic]

yes thank you!! dad that's what i've been trying to say. can we please lynch someone in the pool of pillow bunny/onyx

 

[Ashtot]

And just because somebody doesn't care about the game doesn't mean they're scum - if you're going to have that attitude day one, you might as well lynch somebody who hasn't said a thing at all like DarkOnyx or pillow bunny. But I mean, going after people for legitimate suspicions takes effort I guess. Personally, it's not rune's not caring that raises flags for me, but the genuine defense mode they put up in response to what was said to them.

I'm not sure if you're referring to me or not, but if you are, the reason I voted for Rune is because he already had somebody voting for him. In order to lynch an inactive it would have to be me voting for him because nobody else is going to vote for the others, unless someone persuaded them to. Sonrio had 3 votes and if I kept my vote on Cap, or any of the others, it would be a useless vote.

 

[Pathetic]

i have a bad feeling sonrio is 3rd-party but i can shake it off later probably. he'd probably not play like this as 3rdparty. also i've played w him before so yeah

 

[LaBelleFleur]

Switched my vote to Runeraider based on what I posted about them before, the ongoing discussion & the fact that I'm more suspicious of Sonrio than audino now, but not enough to throw a vote their way today.

 

[Ashtot]

yes thank you!! dad that's what i've been trying to say. can we please lynch someone in the pool of pillow bunny/onyx

Rune and Nikki and cap are in that pool as well if you're talking about inactive players.