I'm not trying to sound rude, because both of them wanted Skye, but.... 'First come, first serve. No reservations.' is stated in the rules, and Ichigo posted first. So I don't think this is really.... fair? :3 I mean, I see you'd feel bad since Angel wanted her badly, but rules are rules?
Same happened to me with Bob on this thread a while back and I'd lost many opportunities to get him. I even checked the rules after to see if I had got the thread mixed up and you gave villagers away differently to first come first serve so I was confused c: