Surprisingly, I have managed to move four villagers from Cocoplum to Big Bear Village (BBV). The permanent residents now include Grizzly, Stiches, Pudge and Teddy (from Cocoplum), Beardo (adopted) and Nate (original villager). I still have to transfer Paula and Pinky in from Cocoplum, which will make eight. And I know I want my ninth villager to be Maple. I have never had her and she will be my normal.
Looking at your list of existing villagers,I'd go for Pekoe.Yeah,she's a normal like Maple but she has a very distinctive look and a fairly nice house.She could be Pinky's kid sister.
first off, I love how you've named the mayor of BBV Goldie! :')
as for your tenth, I'd recommend either pekoe (really cool design + normals are adorable) or klaus, as you've only got one smug and one normal. I've never had either in my towns, but they're my favorites of your choices :>
Pekoe is one of my dreamies, so I gotta throw in a vote for her! She's such a cutie. Charlise is a good option too, I had her in my town and she was really adorable.