Best cranky villager

[mangoe]

So I want to have each type of personality on my island, and I need a cranky villager. I’ve never had a cranky villager before, I mostly have lazys bc they’re a•d•o•r•a•b•l•e.
So what cranky villager is the best?

 

[Hobowire]

I really really really like Spike. He's a big softy on the inside.

 

[justalittlemad]

I adore Roscoe personally with Walt as a close second.

 

[marea]

Grizzly is my favorite cranky in acnh.

 

[Forthefunofit]

Wolfgang
Blue wolf that loves chillin on my island and telling my lazy villagers to take their future more seriously

 

[amylsp]

Static first with Roscoe second.

 

[Florence + The Machine]

The correct answer is Cyd. Elvis and Spike are great too.

 

[mangoe]

Let me go check those villagers out! I may or may have not printed out a list of villagers

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

It's Dobie. Any other answer is objectively wrong

 

[Serabee]

DOBIE. Forever and ever, Dobie will always be best

He's the only one who actually looks OLD. Plus, he has a neat house- I gave him a secluded section of beach on my island and his house looks fantastic on it-

​

I've changed his house a bit since then, but it's still the same concept. Behind his house is a little party beach area. I imagine Dobie shaking his fist and complaining about young 'uns sneaking onto his property... but then he's also secretly bopping along to their young people music
Seriously, I like a lot of crankies, but Dobie will ALWAYS be kind to me!

Post automatically merged: Aug 9, 2020

It's Dobie. Any other answer is objectively wrong

Agreed! He's just the personality personified (...wolfified?)

 

[Dunquixote]

Roscoe and Gaston. When Roscoe gets mad or annoyed, the whites of his eyes turn yellow, which I think is pretty interesting.

Gaston: I initially didn’t care for him or harry who i had in NL, but both actually grew on me - especially Gaston. If I had more room, he’d be one of the first ones I’d invite in spite of his terrible house interior.

 

[saucySheep]

I'd say Spike. I really like the punk theme and the deep voice actually fits his looks. And honestly he's such a sweetie and is always like "Don't slip and fall!!!!!1!!!111"

 

[Serabee]

I'd say Spike. I really like the punk theme and the deep voice actually fits his looks. And honestly he's such a sweetie and is always like "Don't slip and fall!!!!!1!!!111"

The cranky personality, in general, is one of my faves! Like... they're cranky, but they're also completely self-aware that they're stereotypical "grumpy old men" and are totally cool joking about it. And it never takes long for them to reveal their sweet and caring side! They remind me of my late Papa They're tied with sisterly as my favorite personality... but that's basically the female version of them, lol

 

[Mattician]

Static is my favorite cranky villager, and he might be my favorite overall right now.

 

[Minimasher]

Static. enough said

 

[saucySheep]

Oh I also really like Ricky. Have him in new leaf and he is def fav

 

[BluebearL]

Boris: He's a chocolate loving boar with an extravagant house and adorable face enough said. Another favourite of mine is Hopper: he's adorable because of how hilariously cranky he looks as a pudgy penguin.

There are a ton of amazing crankies, t they are equally as cute as any other personality in their own grumpy way.

 

[NyattaSama]

I have Roscoe and Kabuki on my island and I adore them both! Roscoe has always been a favorite of mine and Kabuki has been growing on me. I love Kabuki so much now I even built a kabuki theatre for him lol. Both of them love to sing and I always find them singing in the weirdest places.

 

[Halloqueen]

Cranky is a wonderful personality, definitely my second favorite of the male personalities behind Smug.

Not sure who would fit best for you without knowing the rest of the villagers you have and your personal taste, but here are some of my favorites:

Butch: He's not as desirable for me since I tend to go for designs with more unique aspects, but he might fit with a bunch of Lazies. He's just a good standard rottweiler dog. I had him in my original GameCube town and he showed up again for a time in both City Folk and one of my New Leaf games, but I didn't play City Folk for long and moved him out of New Leaf for new experiences. Regardless, good dog.

Camofrog: I've never had him in a town personally, but I like his design a lot and he could probably fit in here. His face is cute enough when you look past the camouflage. His camouflage ties in well with his house's interior design.

Del: He has a cool metallic, robotic design like Ribbot and Sprocket. I have him in New Leaf rather than New Horizons, but I've read on here that apparently his (and the other two robots) eyes are backlit and look cool at night. Someone else would have to verify that though.

Dobie: Just a good old Wolf. His elderly appearance is unique and he has a cool house.

Hopper: He might look a bit angry because of his eyebrows, but penguins are my favorite animals, and my admittedly biased opinion is that he's probably cute enough to fit in.

Lobo: The other Wolves tend to get most of the attention and love from the playerbase, but Lobo's my favorite. His eyes are really striking and cool. Good simple house inside and out.

Octavian: Not particularly cute, but I always have to mention Octavian when it comes to Cranky villagers because there are only three permanent Octopus villagers and he's the original and my favorite.

Static: He's visually interesting with his light purple fur and yellow and green accents. I could see him among other cute villagers.

Also love Apollo, Boris, Buzz, Kabuki, Knox, Rasher, Vic, and Walt but they don't really fit.

 

[SirSean]

Dobie is the best cranky no doubt. He's got such a sweet personality once you get to know him.