Personally, I like Goldie. Something about her face seems much more gentle and comforting than Bea. IDK, with Bea's eyes, I feel like she could almost pass for a different personality? My personal favorite normal dog is Daisy, though. I had her for a long time in... IDK what game, but she's cute. I still tend to get her and Goldie mixed up, though
I voted Bea because I have her in my town and she's v precious :>
My favorite breed of dog is golden retrievers but Goldie kinda throws me off cause she has spots and goldens don't have spots irl lol (I should know cause I have a golden puppy)
I might have had Goldie in New Leaf (or at least considered moving her in? can't remember, I know I had a different dog villager though at one point), so my vote goes to her. Looks like I'm in the overwhelming majority here.