Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[amazonevan19]

The last part makes no sense. Can you elaborate?

Since we know Byngo's messenger is Ness, and there's another messenger in the game that sent a message to Bianca, it's V E R Y likely that Bianca's messenger is scum and is trying to confuse us. For balance reasons, it'd be really dumb to have two town-aligned messengers. It HAS to be one town, one scum

 

[Byngo]

Becauseeeee I said on a post directly to Byngo at the start of day "Are you Shooketh " to get a direct answer from her. It was only a matter of time before it was revealed to be me because had Byngo jo revealed th part of the PM where I asked her to send a message to me, I wouldn't have revealed it.

aside from dad, probably no one else would’ve even picked up on it

im just gonna go cuz i feel worthless right now

 

[amazonevan19]

I have no reason not to believe it.

this is bad and you should feel bad

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Since we know Byngo's messenger is Ness, and there's another messenger in the game that sent a message to Bianca, it's V E R Y likely that Bianca's messenger is scum and is trying to confuse us. For balance reasons, it'd be really dumb to have two town-aligned messengers. It HAS to be one town, one scum

You're wrong it's me!!!1111 no it's not me lol

 

[amazonevan19]

You're wrong it's me!!!1111 no it's not me lol

 

[PunchyTheCat]

LOL IM DYING

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll stop ****posting now anyways, if Locket wasn't investigated from the Oracle, who would you lynch Evan?

 

[Jacob]

Mafia could've been elected president, and given the same messaging ability. This doesn't really confirm anything about Bianca's message sender necessarily

 

[Heyden]

Punchy, you're blatantly scumreading Locket bc Bianca received an ANONYMOUS message saying Locket is mafia. You do realise we don't know who this ANONYMOUS is, either they're scum framing her, or town with info, or even town lying bc that stuff always happens. Yes you have no reason to not believe it, but what's your reason TO believe it?

And again, here's your daily reminder to condense your posts pls. Hikari who has 10 times less posts than you has probably provided more content than you have, which is pretty sad.

 

[N e s s]

aside from dad, probably no one else would’ve even picked up on it

im just gonna go cuz i feel worthless right now

Knowing him, we both know he would have revealed it.

Byngo, I hold nothing against you outside this. Please don't self deprecate yourself, I'm sorry for yelling at you.

 

[amazonevan19]

Mafia could've been elected president, and given the same messaging ability. This doesn't really confirm anything about Bianca's message sender necessarily

Is this intended to cast shade on Ness? If Ness is scum he deserves the win tbh

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll stop ****posting now anyways, if Locket wasn't investigated from the Oracle, who would you lynch Evan?

Either Rune or Toads/Vanessa. I'd have to seriously re-evaluate which of the millers I doubt more, I'm leaning towards Vanessa

- - - Post Merge - - -

my vote is still on rune after all of this btw; I suggest at least a couple locket voters unvote to prevent potential maj'ing

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Punchy, you're blatantly scumreading Locket bc Bianca received an ANONYMOUS message saying Locket is mafia. You do realise we don't know who this ANONYMOUS is, either they're scum framing her, or town with info, or even town lying bc that stuff always happens. Yes you have no reason to not believe it, but what's your reason TO believe it?

And again, here's your daily reminder to condense your posts pls. Hikari who has 10 times less posts than you has probably provided more content than you have, which is pretty sad.

Mk so my reason to believe it is because if Locket IS scum, then we can trust the Oracle. I know it is a big risk but I think it's worth it.

 

[Jacob]

Is this intended to cast shade on Ness? If Ness is scum he deserves the win tbh

No not at all, but the roles were determined before Trundle knowing if mafia or town would be president, so he wouldn't create a messaging role as scum to be in contrast to the president being town, as you were explaining I think

 

[illunie]

im not sure if i can totally believe that town wouldnt have two messengers, i think its still possible that theres an oracle, espicially if you consider it to be a cop which gives its reading to a random person instead of themselves. this does make it look a lot less likely tho, im probably gonna end up voting for toad instead and then use tomorrows report to consider it

 

[Biancasbotique]

Knowing him, we both know he would have revealed it.

Byngo, I hold nothing against you outside this. Please don't self deprecate yourself, I'm sorry for yelling at you.

Wait, hold on, didn't you encourage Byngo to reveal the message and i dont get why you got that when she actually revealed it!

You mucho loco!

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Also, one messenger, who is town and an Oracle. Not two messengers.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wait, hold on, didn't you encourage Byngo to reveal the message and i dont get why you got that when she actually revealed it!

You mucho loco!

TBH was also thinking about this.

 

[unravel]

I'm still sticking to my vote on toads unless theres something intriguing topic and Biancs you better explain your anon message

 

[Biancasbotique]

Um...I got a message?

 

[amazonevan19]

No not at all, but the roles were determined before Trundle knowing if mafia or town would be president, so he wouldn't create a messaging role as scum to be in contrast to the president being town, as you were explaining I think

ohh I can see your point

Yeah knowing Ness is the messenger who GAINED this ability overnight...it seems that does make my analysis a bit moot, since the other role could have been another townie who randomly gained it too. But what special insight does Bianca's messenger have? Are they an oracle or are contrasting town/scum messaging roles really a thing? If there are contrasting messaging roles, then at least one didn't say anything last night, cuz one message came from Ness.

The fact Ness gained tweeting casts doubt on the whole notion of contrasting roles now...hmmmmm

 

[unravel]

Um...I got a message?

WTF DIDNT U MENTION YOU RECEIVE LOCKET IS MAFIA PM???????? ��

 

[N e s s]

Wait, hold on, didn't you encourage Byngo to reveal the message and i dont get why you got that when she actually revealed it!

You mucho loco!

That was clearly me trying to tell her that I thought I told was okay to reveal it so long as it left no hints it was me AND was trying to tell her I had a plan.