10th Villager: Roscoe or Papi?

[Kitsey]

Please help me decide on my last villager!!! I would really like a horse villager in my town, and I'm having a lot of trouble choosing between Roscoe and Papi. I have 8 villagers right now, in my signature (for those who choose not to see signatures, they are Wolfgang, Snake, Lily, Ruby, Astrid, Marshal, Walker, and Muffy) and I have my heart set on Gayle.

Overall, I like Papi's design a little better, but I like Crankies a little better than Lazies. I like the PWPs they suggest equally, and the appearance of their houses doesn't really matter to me.

So can I have your opinions please? I'll admit that right now I'm leaning towards Roscoe but only because Wolfgang NEVER seems to be outside for me to talk to, and, of course, I might see somebody else entirely in my campsite that I'll pick up on impulse, but..... Does one seem to fit in with my other villagers more than the other? Who do you like better?

 

[Mariah]

Roscoe is a great villager.

 

[TehyaFaye]

Papi is super cute, but if you like Cranky more than Lazy then Roscoe is the better pick. They both look nice.

 

[tamagotchi]

Roscoe, definitely.

 

[Skyzeri]

Papi! I'm biased towards lazy villagers though, and he was an original in my town. It's completely up to you; everyone will have a different opinion based on their experiences. Honestly, I like Roscoe's design better, but Papi's personality.

 

[Kitsey]

That's kind of what I was thinking. I love how unique Crankies' voices are! Buuut lazies are cute too. I think I'll have to spend more time with Wolfgang and Walker to see whose dialog I can stand being repeated more. Sigh. I wish we were able to have two villagers of each personality in our towns. It will probably end up being Roscoe. He'll be a nice contrast with Ruby especially, what with the red eyes, but opposite fur colors. I love how Lazies do the shy emotion so often though, haha.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I think if I plan to have two normals, two crankies would give the game a nice balance.
Thank you everyone for your replies; you've given me a lot to think about

 

[Yay Sweets]

I say Roscoe! Crankies are cool.

 

[ravenkaw]

I like both of them, but I've had Papi more recently so I actually remember his personality.

I find Papi to be very assuming in a derpy way. He always made me giggle.

 

[Pokemanz]

I love Roscoe to death. I would definitely recommend him!

 

[Fairytale]

I have Papi. I really liked him at first, but hes kinda boring now. Roscoe is cool.

 

[Classygirl]

I love love Roscoe he was my ten in first finished town ever. I had had him before but the problem was I had fang and Bruce and so I let all but fang go to much cranky and moved them to other towns. Papi am thinking myself may be good for lazy it is hard to find a good one, Elmer also a horse but if only one slot Roscoe I love but if already have a Cranky I am thinking of ridding stitches for Papi or Clyde myself.

 

[KittyBoton]

Papi!

 

[kamiyama34]

Wow, this would be a really hard choice if I had to make it. I'm in the same boat as I love crankies...but I have Papi in my town and will say that he is absolutely adorable.

In the end I'd probably say Roscoe though....I always cave to crankies, and he is a pretty awesome looking villager!