Sisterly Tiering

[MiniPocketWorld]

It's been a long time since I've seen Tiering, and I thought, why not Tier the sisterly villagers? I wanna see Yours!
✓ Make your Tier- Sisterly
✓✓ Updated Tier with NEW villagers
Mine: Quinn and Faith were forgotten

 

[HappyTails]

Oh these are fun!

Poor Rocket. She's just disliked throughout. I'm sure if they didn't stuff her into that stupid pink outfit, she'd be more liked. They did her dirty.

 

[Firesquids]

I like sisterlys' personality, wish there were more.

 

[Pyoopi]

It makes me sad there's so little of them. They're such a nice personality.

 

[xSuperMario64x]

as you can no doubt see I most certainly have a bias towards sisterly villagers haha

they're probably my favorite villager personality, I relate to them a lot. there isn't really a sisterly villager that I actually dislike. S tier includes some of my favorite villagers of all time, A tier is ones I really like but they're not quite S tier, and B tier are ones I'm slightly indifferent to but I still like them a lot.
only one I ranked kinda low is Ursala and that's bc she was a rude snooty villager in AC:GCN and I have unresolved ties and conflicts w her lol, if I had her in NH and got to hang out w her and see her sisterly personality I would prob end up liking her more.

also am I really the only person (besides possibly @/Pyoopi) who genuinely loves Rocket? she's one of the few gorilla villagers I actually like.


edit: I also somehow didn't notice that Quinn and Faith were missing?? especially considering I literally have Quinn on my island and I love her sm
so Quinn would def be S tier for me, and Faitg would prob be B tier since I like her but the fact that her face is a different color from the rest of her body has always kinda thrown me off lol

 

[Nunnafinga]

I ranked the ucherly girls using snack foods with Cheez-Its being my favorite.I don't hate any of them but there are a few that I hope stay very far away from my islands.

 

[Ravenkitty22]

Sisterly is my favorite personality type in AC, so I had to restrain myself from not putting 90% of them in the top tier. I wish there were more of them.

 

[FoxFeathers]

Sisterly is one of my favs for dialog but man I wish they had more options.

 

[deana]

These are always fun, we definitely need way more sisterly villagers! Currently Flo is who I've got on my island and I would like to try out Phoebe once I unlock the ability to customize villager homes (I just hate her lava house so much).

 

[wuppytime]

oh, fun! i really love the sisterly animals for the most part!
katt and renee specifically are super special to me. i did a pride piece with katt once!

 

[cherrytheone]

Here it is!

Sisterlies are my fav villager personality! Frita and Phoebe are on the top because they're the only ones I've played with so far, to be honest. I don't villager hunt/play with amiibo a lot so in both NL and NH for the most part I ended up only getting one sisterly per game. And I liked them so much that Frita has a permanent place on my island ...and Phoebe... poor Phoebe, because on my NL town, Starfell, I have already decided to let everyone move on their own (when they ping me I always let them move out) and I can't make myself make an exception for my girl Pheebs.

The other girls are based on looks mostly, but also if they look fun. Ursala's in B because she's cute but she was rude to me on my GC town. When you get to the koala thing before the penguin on C tier (idr their names LOL) they start gettin' uggo. I still love sisterlies tho. Now that I'm looking at it again the chicken kinda looks cute

 

[Venn]

Agnes will always be top Sisterly, with Muffy close as well.
I kid of just placed these in order my which I would likely invite to my island.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Spoiler: old

Faith, Ursala, and Charlise top tier uchi

edit: updated mine.. tier lists are weird for me in that my opinions on some villagers change based on how I feel at the moment. So a couple of villagers have moved up or down on my tierlist already!

 

[MiniPocketWorld]

Oops, yeah it looks like Faith and Quinn are both missing!
The worst part is I didn't even notice..

Welp I'd probably place Quinn at the beginning of C or near the end of B. Faith would go before the rabbit.

Here is one that includes them:
Updated Sisterly Tier List

 

[S.J.]

I find it so hard to rank villagers, especially because I don’t think any of them deserve to be bottom tier! I haven’t met all of the villagers, so I had to base it on design as well. Overall, I love the sisterly villager type though. They are really sweet and funny, and often quirky too.

 

[Xara]

these are super fun! i’ve missed the tiering threads haha.

the designs are hit or miss for me, but i love the sisterly personality itself! the dialogue is a good mix of funny and heartwarming, and i love the “hard on the outside, but soft on the inside” aspect of them! sisterly was one of my favourite personalities in new leaf, because if i was close enough friends with a sisterly villager, they’d give me medicine whenever i got stung by wasps lol. i always thought it was so sweet, and that it really helped make them seem like a tough, caring big sister. i’d love more sisterly villagers!

and don’t feel bad that you didn’t notice some of the sisterly villagers missing from the first tier list — i didn’t notice at first either, and i literally have quinn on my island.

 

[xSuperMario64x]

When you get to the koala thing before the penguin on C tier (idr their names LOL) they start gettin' uggo.

"the koala thing" lmao rip Canberra

 

[river]

Organized from most to least likely to beat me up.

 

[zissou]

JUSTICE FOR PAULA WHO WAS NOT IN THE FIRST ITERATION OF THIS
i refuse to speak on sisterlies without the presence of mother
also yes i chose violence in my tierlist and i will stand by it

Sisterly is my favorite personality. (In my head I still call them Uchi, like we did on Tumblr in my New Leaf days. Wait, did everyone do that or just me? I can't remember...) They've got a perfect combination of sass, sweetness, and humor that feels like a genuine personality (food and sports do not a personality make). They make me laugh and they feel real because they're imperfect, but trying to better themselves without taking themselves too seriously.

Wow I am waxing poetic about sisterlies and they deserve it all. Best girls <3

 

[Moritz]

One of the best personalities dialogue wise, but their designs leave a lot to be desired. So this list does not mean I think a villager is actually an A tier, just in comparison to other sisterly villagers.