I can't imagine Jack looking like a normal NPC villager if he takes his mask off. I can imagine him having pure black fur or dark dark purple skin. But what does his face look like? His he a wolf? Cat? Redd's evil cousin? Post your thoughts about Jack the King of Halloween.
Oh my gosh I never even thought about this. I think he'd be really cute and innocent because if he were a scary wolf or something there wouldn't be a need for the mask unless he wants to hide his true identity.
hahaha interesting thread. I think because acnl is a relatively cute game that once jack takes the pumpkin off it will reveal a very cute male witch ^^
He's classified as a specter, so I imagine him as such. If the jack-o'-lantern isn't his actual head, I imagine there's simply nothing underneath. Considering he can vanish and teleport, I'm pretty sure it isn't just some animal in a costume like Zipper T. Bunny. The existence of Wisp might throw a wrench into that theory, but I like running with it anyway.
I don't think he's an animal, myself. He's the "Czar of Halloween" so I'm pretty sure he's a ghost or spirit, and the pumpkin he's wearing is either his actual head or there's nothing underneath.
I like to think he's either a black cat since those are popular around this time as trickery and whatnot, or even somewhat based off the headless horseman who uses a pumpkin for a head.