Do you always get the same villager?

[Cass123]

Phil appeared in my first town and when I reset. He also resides in my husband's town.

 

[Licorice]

Gosh I've noticed there's about a handful of villages I've gotten a thousand times. Mitzi being one of them as well. Rasher is another. Bob, Bree. In Wild World I got Moe and Rod heaps too. Thankfully they've stayed at bay since NL.

Update. UGH, talk of the devil, Mitzi just moved in! -.-

CREEPY

 

[Story]

Paula.. hate her appears and ruin my towns so I restart a lot

Same I get Paula very often. :/

 

[mermaidshelf]

WINNIE! I've had her in EVERY Animal Crossing game (well main title games anyway). It actually makes me happy to see a familiar face. She's kinda like my big sis, watching over me in a new home and she leaves when I'm more settled.

 

[MayorKatlyn]

Naomi is one of my favs. I didn't like her at first but then she became my bestie. <3

 

[MillySoSilly]

I've reset my town maybe 5 times before and every single town had Colton. Even right now on my second town, Colton moved in. I don't mind him but I think it's funny. So he'll be a dreamie in my 3rd town.