☆ DarkNightMoon ☆
If
iLoveYou was smart enough to get
Truffle modkilled, do you all really think she'd be so dumb as to expose a scum mate so easily? Note that her post defending
DarkNightMoon came
after attention was brought to the fact
LittleBeary had defended her. Also note that by this point
iLoveYou already knew she had been caught.
Truffle actually posted the screenshot about
iLoveYou just
sixteen minutes after the post where she defended
DNM.
iLoveYou role claimed blue to
Truffle immediately as soon as roles when out: so there is no doubt she already knew she was a goner by this point. I think this is a case of a mafia member just making a last minute effort to confuse town before their inevitable death.
In short, I think
iLoveYou intended to frame
DarkNightMoon. The timing seems too coordinated. Being a new member,
DNM was an easy target - especially as
LittleBeary's post about her was actually the considered a key piece of evidence at the time
iLoveYou made her post / was modkilled.
Unless stronger evidence is raised against
DarkNightMoon I won't be voting for her.
(umm, you are a girl right?)
☆ Tom ☆
Karen said:
Nonetheless I'd like to bring Tom to your attention. No concrete evidence but some weird things.
1) He hasn't posted his usual player tier
2) Has been quiet and only posted when I called him out earlier
Tom's player tiers aids the mafia more than they do town. I'm glad he didn't post one.
The points raised against him so far imply that he is careless. Scum are the most careful of all when it comes to leaving a trace. Based on previous games (especially Mafia IV),
Tom has shown that when he's scum he can can act a lot more tactfully than that. If he is scum this game then his standards are slipping.
☆ BlueLeaf ☆
I agree with the points
Superpenguin raised against
BlueLeaf, and I would also like to add one of my own. This comment from Day 1 caught my attention:
BlueLeaf said:
(Also, if oath2order PM's you saying he's a DT / Cop, don't fall for it easily, if he hasn't done so already)
Any town player shouldn't be bothered by a fake DT PM, right? Especially when the only miller this game knows they're the miller... so why should any town-aligned player feel the need to make a comment about this?
Well, providing my theory about
DarkNightMoon being framed is correct, then this post can be further backed up by the fact
BlueLeaf was actually talking to DNM. To me, this reads like a scum player laying the groundwork for what
LittleBeary and
iLoveYou later posted. With
Harry Potter in the game, framing players is likely something mafia had to begin structuring early on to make up for poor role claims (remember
Truffle caught 4/6 scum,
not including
LittleBeary?).
Also, let me show you the rest of the post I took that snippet from:
BlueLeaf said:
DarkNightMoon said:
Anybody have anyone else scummy? (don't stay on kit topic please)
Maybe you can try and find them for yourself? If you need help, ask Truffle for some advice, he is confirmed Town after all.
(Also, if oath2order PM's you saying he's a DT / Cop, don't fall for it easily, if he hasn't done so already)
To answer your question though, I don't have someone that is scummy, but has been lurking: Kayla / iLoveYou. I figure she's doing some analyzing or traveling into PM land, since you can never tell with her.
This was posted just three hours into the game, so it's a bit early to properly call out someone on lurking. As I mentioned earlier,
iLoveYou role claimed immediately after roles went out because
Truffle contacted her as soon as he got his role - so even this early in the game she knew she was going to die quickly. Perhaps she told
BlueLeaf to make an early comment to protect himself later?
☆ Kit ☆
Although I'd love to say, "please could a vig just shoot her?" we've also got to remember that we have no medics left. We shouldn't lower town numbers unnecessarily; so if and when we do decide we need to be rid of her (mafia won't touch her until she starts to tick them off too) it needs to be properly justified - e.g. she's either scum or seriously harming the hunt for scum.
