Dora is my favorite normal villager because she was a permanent part of my City Folk town. She was either a starter or moved in really early. While my other long term villagers would move out after 1-2 years, Dora stayed in my town the entire time I played.
Lolly is a close second because she reminds me of my cat and was in my New Leaf town for a few years.
My favorite is Molly! I'm not a huge fan of normal type personality, but their designs are some of my favorites, they're so natural and cute. I wish they had some better dialogue, though.
i absolutely love norma right now. she was one of my first three after the initial two, and i didn't like her at first but she really grew on me. she's really sweet and was the first villager to give me a nickname - "pumpkin" lol.
Gayle, gotta love my alligators. I don't like pink too much but I love how it's integrated in her design!
I also had Merengue but I gifted her away after Audie showed in my campsite (Wolves are my favorite species with Alligators, and I was curious about both Audie herself and peppy villagers), made sure to find an excited new owner too ^^. She has a really original an unique design for me, and also made me appreciate pastel pink too hahaha
I wish it wasn't gender locked though, some normal/sweet males and jock/lazy girls would be nice
Chevre is my favorite but I also love Alice and Coco! I love so many of the normal villager designs but I find their personalities nice but almost too agreeable so I dont want too many on my island.