Would you care?

[sn0wxyuki]

If somebody comment on your town, saying your town doesn't look that great and should have this and that changes, your pwps placement are not so good and so, basically not a nice comment on your town or whatever you have.

Would you consider taking their advice and change or you will just ignore as it is YOUR TOWN and YOU LIKE IT that matter?

 

[twerkstrider]

i love gaming and am interested in a wide variety!! so, for me, i have other games i can worry about putting work into and challenge myself, but.... i think animal crossing is game that gives me a chance to just relax. i don't really mind what people think of my town as it's purely for my recreation.

not to say, though, that others can't use it as a creative and architectural outlet!! when others put hard work into their towns, they look absolutely lovely but me personally? not really into it and don't really care B)

what about you, snow?

 

[sn0wxyuki]

I currently working on my town! And also to others it might not be nice or perfect or so and also my dreamies? Non of them is popular, maybe Molly, but i love them to bits!! Yes my town is not perfect but I love it! Agree with what you said! Cause it purely my creation so I should happy and should not affected by some comments^^

 

[Chibi Kafu]

It depends on what they tell me change. If it's something I agree with them on, I'd change it. If I like it how it is, I'd keep it that way.

If people give me rude comments on things that I worked hard on, I just say 'thank you for your constructive criticism.' or something like that.

 

[Chessa]

If they want me to change things I really like I won't, if they say change.... and I think hey, good idea, I might just do that

 

[Mariah]

I wouldn't care. I'm aware my town sucks and could use a ton of improvements. I probably wouldn't follow their advice though.

 

[mariop476]

I wouldn't care. My town isn't supposed to be super developed; I don't have roads for a reason. The PWPs I have are to basically make the game feel more natural: benches, bridges, lampposts, etc. I ENJOY the seven seas of flowers which have consumed my town (maybe).
If someone recommended I change any of this and were kind, I'd probably say thanks but no thanks, if someone were rude, I'd probably be a bit more curt.

 

[ACupOfTea]

See, I like constructive criticism. If someone was being rude to me and telling me what to change, I'm not sure I'd listen to them. I'll happily take advice from people offering it in a polite manner though.

 

[Libra]

If the criticism was constructive, then yes. I'm aware my town is underdeveloped and doesn't look all that pretty, but that's okay. I just consider it as a work in progress. ^_^

 

[Punchies]

I probably wouldn't care one bit lol. I can do what I want to do with my town.

 

[tinybutterfly75]

My town is for my pleasure. It's not themed or highly developed. I play to relax and have fun. I like my town fine, but it's definitely a work in progress, changing all the time.

I am not sure I would even ask someone else to rate my town or give advice, but like I said, I am just playing for fun, not to make a themed village.

If you are happy with your town, just enjoy it.

 

[Strawbswild]

I would say, take the advice if you're looking for advice and are unsure of things. If they are saying hey your town sucks, it should be like x town then I would personally ignore them. Animal crossing encourages creativity, and having a different insight that no one else has. This exists even if it's just a bit different, it's different no matter what.I mean that's why things are randomly spawned whether it's trees, rocks, houses, etc cause it's not supposed to be the same as anyone else's. Though.. having some people guiding you and giving you good advice in lieu of what you want your ideal town (help/criticism with unsure pwp placement/tips on roads/Etc) isn't bad, just the subjective nitpicking and personal opinions on other's towns that aren't their own ideal is what's bad. So honestly my opinion and many others are: Do whatever you want to your town that makes you enjoy it and makes you happy~

 

[Bowie]

I didn't buy the game for someone else, did I?

 

[PurplPanda]

Right now, my town is unfinished, so if someone gave me advice, I would probably take it.

 

[Stalfos]

I would ban them. BAN THEM, I say.

 

[akirb]

I love my town and don't care what others think. Its mine and that makes it perfect for me ^^ (kinda corny, but whatever..)

 

[Bowie]

I love my town and don't care what others think. Its mine and that makes it perfect for me ^^ (kinda corny, but whatever..)

That's a really good attitude to have, my friend.

 

[Primalia]

I love my town, it's like coming home when I play but if someone can see an idea that might improve it I'll look at it.
Change can be good but advice is just that, advice.

 

[Kanapachi]

I honestly wouldn't care. :|

I don't care what other people say about my town, tbh.

 

[Salem]

I don't mind constructive criticism. That doesn't mean I have to do what they say. But sometimes if I'm unsure of something, or I don't even know if I like what I've done, then it's nice to have a second (or third or fourth) opinion. I mean, they may also validate something that I was unsure of and make me happier with it than I was. If they made a suggestion that I didn't like, I'd just say thanks for the input but I'll probably leave it.

Also, I wouldn't want every player to have a cookie cutter town. Just because one person thinks something should be one way, doesn't mean that everyone has to do it that way. So that's just something to keep in mind when posting in a review thread. I like to see variety, and people do different things with their towns. People just post in review threads to get an outside take on their town. Nothing wrong with that. It's nice to get a second perspective bc they may see or notice things that you don't. Especially since you play in your town everyday.