Why do people sell villagers?

I can understand this from both sides on why some people would want to trade a very popular villager for a lot of cash since some people are very keen to do whatever it takes to get the said villager, on the other hand I think I can see what the OP means when trading for a villager is cruel (forgive me if I got the wrong idea) when some needy people want a certain villager but is not able to afford it due to not being able to invest in the time to make cash and not to mention some people won't get the chance to make money due to being busy in RL and may not have the chance to be able to play at the right time of the day.

Though personally, I would just be glad to trade a villager for another one or give it away regardless of how popular it is since I really do not need so much cash and plus just giving a villager away is going to help me enough for any future plans in my town.
 
@ Patchwork Thank you, you were able to understand my view point and thank you for posting your opinion. :)
 
No poor person wants an expensive villager more than someone willing to pay, because they aren't working to get un-poor. This isn't the real world, where jobs are scarce for some people. It's Animal Crossing. You can TT, you can do turnips, you can even dupe if you're really desperate. You're poor because you don't want to put in any effort, or you aren't putting in enough effort, but you expect to get something other people put effort in for anyway. It's selfish.

Some people have lives. -.-
They go to school and work, they do not have time to spend every other hour on AC getting bells. It is not selfish neither can you measure someones desire for a villager by how many bells they are willing to make for it. I'm poor. I put in a lot of my time to AC but I still have work to do and things in my real life come first. I can't say to my boss ''Not coming in today, Marshal is on auction and I need to make bells to get him''. I give away villagers, the people I give them to are not selfish. To say its effort to give people villagers is laughable. I deserve nothing for giving people villagers for I have done bugger all to deserve a reward.
 
I always rather trade villagers than sell them!
Though most of the time the other person gets their animal out first and I can't take it- :)

I agree with lyla- though I'm on summer holidays at the moment!
 
Last edited:
It seems like a cruel thing to do, esp at the prices they are going for. Honestly people I see why you would sell items or even trade villagers but selling?! Really? I hope I am not the only one that feels this way.

A tough dilemma. In the end, that person is providing a Object that's DESIRABLE to the buyer. Don't let these transactions affect you, or the way you play. =)
 
I would only pay for villagers I really like, but glad I could trade Ed for Stitches.
I mean If I have a villager I don't like I will just give it away for free, if they want to give me an little
thank you gift, thats fine to me.
 
Selling in-demand villagers is just one more way of making bells in the game. On the one hand the sellers are chided for selling villagers because sellig villagers isn't necessary in order to make money since there are plenty of ways to make bells in the game. Then, on the other hand, the simultaneous claim is made that selling villagers to those with a lot of bells isn't fair because some players are poor. If a lot of bells are very easy to come by (and I agree that they are), what's the excuse for players without millions of bells in the bank? I have to agree with those who are saying that if you can't afford a villager it's your own fault. If it really meant something to you, you play the stalk market and go beetle and shark harvesting on the island every night to make the money. That would be the priority in order to get your dream villager quickly. The people who have the bells put in the time. Those complaining about others buying and selling villagers sounds like sour grapes to me.
 
I just don't get how people can associate the word "cruel" with this. How is it cruel? Is the animal being neglected or affected in any way? To say that "there are poor people that want it too"- theres many things I would like both in real life and in the game but I don't go around saying "well I'm poor and can't afford it, so its cruel to charge me for it" in most places that would be considered begging which, lots of people don't tolerate. If someone is so poor and has literally 0 time to ever make any type of bells, then why does begging for a certain villager even matter if you can never find time to play your game? In the time you are sitting here crying about it and the time you spend with the animals in game you could be making bells. :cool: Not to mention, I don't know why someone would be affected by people selling if there are so many people willing to give away free villagers like you guys have said.
 
Last edited:
I cannot stress this enough when I see these posts.. it's how people choose to play. If it's not affecting you then it should not be a problem.
There are many highly sought at villagers.. and there have been more and more people giving villagers away. After seeing the popularity of said villagers, people thought "Hey.. if I can make some money off of these villagers, I could use that for my own goals in the game."
Granted, some people are thinking selfishly while selling villagers. I guess I know where you're coming from because honestly, I don't see how you can possibly use 70 million bells in this game.
I've sold villagers for around 10 million, and it's all gone to a good cause in the game. I've been using it to pay off 2 houses, which is not a cheap thing. That villager was going to a great home and I received money to aid me in the game.
I'm just tired of people thinking that selling/purchasing villagers is such a bad thing. It's become a really good economy and it's helped a lot of people to reach their dream villages.
 
Some people have lives. -.-
They go to school and work, they do not have time to spend every other hour on AC getting bells. It is not selfish neither can you measure someones desire for a villager by how many bells they are willing to make for it. I'm poor. I put in a lot of my time to AC but I still have work to do and things in my real life come first. I can't say to my boss ''Not coming in today, Marshal is on auction and I need to make bells to get him''. I give away villagers, the people I give them to are not selfish. To say its effort to give people villagers is laughable. I deserve nothing for giving people villagers for I have done bugger all to deserve a reward.

Everyone has lives, doll. Not just you. Some of us can manage our free time to get what we want, ie, villagers. Others can't. Too bad for them. Done with this thread, gonna go roll in my money now :D
 
I never said its a bad thing (hate repeating that)
I am just stating an opinion and seeing how others feel.
If we argue it's fine

I am not attacking their views I just disagree with it.
 
Everyone has lives, doll. Not just you. Some of us can manage our free time to get what we want, ie, villagers. Others can't. Too bad for them. Done with this thread, gonna go roll in my money now :D

Still, some people have much more free time than others, it's not just about management. I agree with Lyla's point.
 
I never said its a bad thing (hate repeating that)
I am just stating an opinion and seeing how others feel.
If we argue it's fine

I am not attacking their views I just disagree with it.

If you believe it's cruel, I'm pretty sure that's the equivalent of bad. Worse actually. It's kind of offensive .__.
 
I find it a little bit silly. At the beginning when we all first got the game we gave them away so freely and it was really nice to have that kind of thing going on. Although I totally understand why they've gotten a price tag nowadays
 
No poor person wants an expensive villager more than someone willing to pay, because they aren't working to get un-poor. This isn't the real world, where jobs are scarce for some people. It's Animal Crossing. You can TT, you can do turnips, you can even dupe if you're really desperate. You're poor because you don't want to put in any effort, or you aren't putting in enough effort, but you expect to get something other people put effort in for anyway. It's selfish.

Excuse me, but some people are busy working and have little to no time to do all that. Though money is "easy to get" as in by getting into the stalk market and trying to make your billions, it indeed DOES takes patience and luck. You have to find a person with a good price, and within a week or so, they rot if you don't get over the price you have paid for, therefore make no budget. It can take hours or even up to DAYS to find a person with all that, something most people on here, including myself don't have. I have literally seen people loose BILLIONS because they could not find a person with a good price. I can sell all the fish and beetles I want, but to accumulate for lost time, it will take FOREVER to get up to the asking price of most people for "75 million bells". Why should we be called "lazy" and "selfish" for not being able to get "sufficient funds" for a character that doesn't even have a price to begin with? Because we have a life? Because we work hard every day and need to provide for our children and families? Oh yes, that's very "selfish" of us. It is a game after all. Take it too seriously and something is wrong. For those that literally spend hours on getting this money, they are either very young and not in school for summer break or not in school at ALL, or they are un-employed and have hours to waste. Simple as that. We people that work also have the right to buy a game and play for our enjoyment, and get the things all you claim is "For those that take this game seriously and put heart into it"

So, if by what you are saying is true, because I don't have 175 million bells on me, are you saying I don't deserve the character I want because I am too busy using the time I have when NOT working my butt off to try to make this money?

If you feel that "only people who have the time to actually play this game should be able to get what they want because they waste hours of their day doing nothing but playing for a character that isn't real and that they are worth it shows their sheer determination better than you" is what you preach, than that is truly sad imo. You mention duping and all that, but for it to ruin my game, it truly isn't worth it. I have had people dupe and loose literally EVERYTHING they have, so does that make it their fault for taking your advice but not duping correctly? Of course not.

I understand that getting these villagers are hard and they are a rare commodity etc, but, what about those that put no effort into getting those characters and are charging with a price as high as that? You mentioned that people who put a high price on certain villagers has tried and tried to get this character, and all that. If that is, then why aren't they keeping them? If you try all that for a character YOU want, only to sell it for money that is, in your opinion "easy to obtain" then sorry, but you never cared for that character to begin with. You spend all these memories and all that for that character you love only to give it away? Is your excuse "but it was to make that person, who really wanted it happy!" if that's the case, you would have given it away to him/her for free then, because "love and care" doesn't come with a price.

People DO have the right to do what they want. I agree there. It's their game. Sell away if you want, but I just have a problem with what you preach. You sold your "beloved Ankha" for bells that are "apparently" easy to get. So, what does that make you? If you have SOOOO much money and can get these bells, why sell it? Why not give it for free then? I'm sorry, but it shows you are just a hypocrite in the matter. If you literally feel that you did all that work to "get this character" just to sell it, then that just proves you did it for the bells, and nothing more.
 
Last edited:
Everyone has lives, doll. Not just you. Some of us can manage our free time to get what we want, ie, villagers. Others can't. Too bad for them. Done with this thread, gonna go roll in my money now :D

That post.. cringe!
Some people manage their free time to do more important things like social lives and volunteering. I'm sure if I stopped volunteering, being social and having a job I could laze around at home and get bells all day, but I'd rather not thanks. Some younger people may not be allowed too much time on their games. It makes no sense to say 'If you have lots of bells clearly you like this villager more than that person'. A lot of older people who have grown up with the series love some of these villagers but simply don't have the time to waste away on their 3ds' all summer long.
 
The trading/selling of villagers is a completely new process for the games. Since it's so easy to get villagers to move into a specific persons town it was bound to wind up being monetized.

I like the idea of trading villagers or giving them away, but bringing money into it is silly. In my opinion at least.


Also, keep the debating civil.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top