I voted for Peggy because she is truly the best one out of that bunch. I had her in my town but I let her go because I really didn't like her sadly lol but if I had to choose between all the pigs I would choose her again. Gala ain't bad either!
Rasher! He's not very cute and probably not popular at all but he lived in my town for quite a long time and I really grew to like him and his crochety ways. He gave me a TON of PWPs too.
I'd definitely say Agnes, she's a great underrated uchi and I absolutely love her coloring. She's got a cool house too. Rasher is a very close second though, he's ugly in such a charmingly adorable way.
Lucy. She's so kind.
When I started playing AC:NL (in my sister's town) Lucy and my character Lilly moved in on the same day. We're fated to be friends XD
His name in Japanese is "Hakase", or professor! He's a mad scientist. A Frankenstein mad scientist! With a lab and everything!
I never had him before but he quickly became my close friend. He requested the first PWP in Rumble - the instrument shelter - one of my absolute favorites that none of my jocks have ever requested (looking at you, Bam rrrrg)
I believe he is the nicest non jock-y jock I've ever had. Luv u Cobb!
I know he won't win on here because very few people have ever had him. But he is a winner in my heart for sure.