Who's the Scariest Villager ? - Themed Polls

[Raccoon Goon]

I voted Coco thanks to those soulless eyes, but I stumbled across something (?) called Clay on an island once and nearly jumped out of my skin! Not sure what he was supposed to be, but he was terrifying.

Clay? The hamster? I have him on my island, he's kinda sweet but also really creepy sometimes, so, you're on to something there. lol

 

[Ciary]

Coco for sure. I love her but she's scary

I'm also scared of peanut.
She looks cute and huggable, but she's a serial killer! I'm sure of it!
A friend of mine has her on her their island and has shared some scary things they've said. like making comments about hiding things, becoming really nervous when she sees you with a shovel and asking you in panic if you found something. also giving a gravestone and then saying they're the bestest of best friends

 

[Barney]

Clay? The hamster? I have him on my island, he's kinda sweet but also really creepy sometimes, so, you're on to something there. lol

I didn't get that he was a hamster. I thought he was a bear!

I approached the campfire while he has his back to the camera, then he turned around and those eyes freaked me out!

 

[petrichr]

I can see the cute appeal of every villager except Ribbot and Raddle... like what the hell... Robot frog and creepy surgeon frog. Nope nope nope. Even Coco's dead eyes have some "cute" appeal in that freakish way.

 

[Raccoon Goon]

I didn't get that he was a hamster. I thought he was a bear!

I approached the campfire while he has his back to the camera, then he turned around and those eyes freaked me out!

Clay is a hamster, definitely. lol And he freaked me out at first as well, so I completely understand. I've kinda grown somewhat fond of him tho. I'd be sad if he asked to move away from my island. His weirdness adds to my gaming experience, haha.

 

[Manon_Despoina]

Voted for Coco. I hate it when things have no eyes.. hers are only empty sockets. Big NO for me!

 

[Feraligator]

Rasher and his angry face or happy face ...

 

[Weiland]

I love Coco! She's not that scary. I think Rodeo is the creepiest out of them all.

 

[thisisausername]

Rasher and his smile D:

Rasher is so cute to me i love him


I voted Rodeo because like others said, he looks like a demon but he'd be cool to have on my island!

 

[Sheep Villager]

I voted other:

Chadder.

It's the holes man. It's the holes. I know I will most likely be alone on this one so I guess this is the hill I die on.

I love Pietro so I'm not sure if I should be rooting for him or not. ​

 

[stiney]

I voted Pietro and other for Stitches. Toys that come to life is never gonna end well for the humans.

 

[airpeaches]

Coco is a favorite of mine but I can't deny her frightening appearance so I voted her her, though I do love the design choice of making her a gyroid bunny.

I still remember when I first saw her on GameCube as a kid; she scared me but we quickly became friends when I realized she was a sweetie. However her exposed facial orifices are certainly weird and a little startling to look at sometimes, lol.

If I'd thought of him I definitely would've voted Raddle under 'Other,' but he didn't occur to me! I find him adorable but also scary in theory, since he's doctor themed but also a poisonous frog.

Edit: I changed my vote so it was for Coco and Other, Raddle!

 

[Hobowire]

Spike

 

[Feferily]

Chief.

 

[Le Ham]

Chow. Probably the only villager I could actually get nightmares of lol. I didn't use to find him terrifying, but the more you think about him... his coloring... his face... yikes

 

[Alicia]

I'm looking forward to more polls from you! I voted for Coco and Pietro.
I think Coco is cute, but also a little scary with her eyes and mouth!
I don't mind Pietro as much now that I met him on a mystery island.
I still don't want him on my island though.

 

[*The Oakboro Mayor*]

Ok so I might be the only one who sees this, but does anyone else think Tammy is absurdly creepy? Her eyes just give me chills, she’s just so... unnerving to me!
I also voted for Coco as well. I like her as a villager, but I still think she is a bit creepy! She is sweet though, ngl!

Spoiler: just pure terror

 

[lulu9956]

Moose for sure.

If he ever showed up on my island I think I would have to delete my save file

(also Pietro is an angel and would never hurt anyone)

 

[Yujian]

Obviously it's this guy

 

[stiney]

Ok so I might be the only one who sees this, but does anyone else think Tammy is absurdly creepy? Her eyes just give me chills, she’s just so... unnerving to me!
I also voted for Coco as well. I like her as a villager, but I still think she is a bit creepy! She is sweet though, ngl!

Spoiler: just pure terror

Definitely creepy. Reminds me of Apple’s creepiness.