Muffy. Freshman year, my friend randomly started calling me Muffy and it stuck, so when I found out there was an Uchi (my favorite personality) named Muffy, I knew I had to have her.
Apart from any villagers that I'd loved in WW.. (And Simon from CF)
I basically had my first sights set on Eugene and Skye.. Those two villagers jumped out to me more than any others.. When the game was finally released in the UK, I also got my sights set on Erik and Tucker
I also loved the idea of some of the older villagers coming back that I'd never really experienced before.. I loved the look of Ozzie, Bangle and Cheri
Lily
Ever since my friend stole her from my WW game in 2010
I had to reclaim her
I searched
Two copies of WW
And one of CF
And it took a tumblr post for NL to finally get her again <3
Beau!! He was also the first one I got and I still have him :'D I didn't know anything about plot resetting then either so I'm pretty lucky in put his house in a alright spot!
My first dreamy outside of the Celadon starters was probably Poppy or Mira. I really wanted them, I thought they were adorable, but tbh I don't care for them much now. I saw Mira in my campsite while I was plot resetting the other day, and she was kind of weird-looking. I still think Poppy is cute, but I prefer Peanut over her.
Julian ... I was intrigued to see who this popular villager was who had the same name as my brother, was surprised that it was a funky blue unicorn ahah. I just had to have him, mr fabulousness..
Tabby & Tangy. Tangy was one of the villagers that I fell in love with before I even received the game, however I never ended up getting her. When first watching the villagers I had totally overlooked Tabby. And once I did notice her... Tangy was 100% replaced.
Well, my first dreamy was Diana, although she was one of my starter villagers. Absolutely adore her. I don't really have any dreamies, though. I'm trying to get all the deer, but that doesn't mean they're my favourites.