Who should I move out?

[smallpeach]

I'm having a huge conflict who I should move out of my personal town. I have wanted to move in Chevre for a long time, but have never gone through with it. I decided to move her in, but I'm not sure who she should replace. Here is what I've come up with-

>Scoot
Pros: if he moved our, my town aesthetic would be more uniform
Cons: no jock personality in town; one less male character; Scoot is god therefore he must stay

>Lily
Pros: replacing normal personality with normal
Cons: i love frog villagers how they don't use umbrellas ahhh; she was in my gamecube town and I have her now for memory's sake; SHE LIVES IN FRONT OF A POND HOW CUTE

>Marina
Pros: again, normal replaces normal
Cons: but octopuuuussss ;v;

guys please help I want my goat bab

 

[Cascade]

It's up to you If i were you i would definitely replace either Marina/Lily for Chevre :3 3 personalities in one town is kinda boring.

 

[SpookyMemes]

I would say Scoot cause imo jock villagers are super annoying (but it's funny cause one of my fav villagers is a jock lmao), and if you really care about your town's aesthetic, then give Scoot the boot

I just looked Scoot up and he's so cute!! Aww

 

[Barnabus_i_am]

I would kick out Marina, because from your descriptions it seems like you are the least attached to her. Having three normals would definitely get boring as well, so you definitely should keep Scoot, and you clearly love Lily. Marina is the one who should leave, in my opinion.

 

[Mars Adept]

I voted Marina because it seems like you love Scoot and Lily more, but it's up to you.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I really don't like Scoot too much so I voted for him. I think you should get rid of the villager you like the least, though.

 

[mitfy]

marina, i think.

 

[junebuggy.99]

Jock villagers are stupid imo, thats why I was eternally grateful when they made Leopold a smug villager in NL (he was a jock on AC:GCN and it was terrible).

Not only that but you said that Scoot doesn't fit your town aesthetic, so that and the fact that he's a jock would be enough to convince me to get him out.

 

[amazonevan19]

I'd move out Marina just based on your description - it seems like you have much more attachment to Scoot and Lily

 

[Spooky.]

I picked Scoot just because Lily is so cute and Marina is sweet

 

[Charcolor]

marina seems to have the least cons. and it seems like lily definitely has to stay in your town lol...and it might be bland to have 3 normals in the same town. that's just me though, in the end it's up to you!

 

[Flare]

Would personally get rid of Scoot.
What are your other villagers btw?

 

[Sweetley]

I would keep Scoot because having different personalities in the town gives more variety. Also it looks
like you really like Lily, so I think you should keep her too. Marina seems to be the one which you are
least attached to (at least I read it out of your descriptions). So I would say replace Marina.

 

[abbydoll]

If it were my decision, I would move Marina out.
Lily is adorable.
And Scoot. I can't hear his name without thinking of Vinesauce. He's just great. I would keep him forever.