Who should I keep?

[LeapDayTown]

Lately I''ve been changing up my dreamies, which means I'm going to have to get rid of either Marshal or Poppy - and I really can't decide because I love them both!

I have other smugs and normals in my town so I wouldn't be left without that personality..

Which would you keep?

 

[Fleshy]

I prefer Marshal, so I'd keep him!

but honestly it's up to you! Who do you like more? Who would fit in with you town more?

 

[namiieco]

I'd much rather keep marshal, if I were you.
If you like poppy better your could sell marshal for some tbt tho

 

[Xara]

I honestly like Poppy more. But it's up to you.

 

[Altarium]

This is hard, because I love them both as well. Poppy is ADORABLE and very underrated, but there's many cute normals you could replace her with. Marshal may be hard to get again if you ever regret letting him go, but it's up to you in the end.

 

[maplecheek]

I had both and decided to keep Poppy. Marshal is not my favorite smug.

Tough decision!

 

[HopeForHyrule]

I prefer Poppy over Marshal (overrated, IMO), but it's really up to you.

Is there a certain color scheme you're going for in your town? That could maybe help with the choosing...

Also, as much as I adore the normals, their dialogue is probably the most...bland out of all the personality types, so if you have other normals in your town that you like more than Poppy, it may not be a bad idea to let her go. And that's really hard for me to say because I love Poppy, lol.

 

[Brittnay]

It's entirely up to you, but I personally prefer Poppy.

 

[A r i a n e]

I like both, but I think I like Poppy better. Marshal is everywhere!

 

[Corrie]

I like Marshal best. C:

 

[Lethalia]

I've never had Marshal so I don't really know him, but I kind of know Poppy & I think she's absolutely adorable! Definitely underrated. If you let Marshal go, you could sell him for a nice amount of TBT, but if you ever regretted it later, he might be really expensive to retrieve. Plus he's so high in demand, so it'd probably take a while, too. Very tough decision though, they're both cute.

 

[chibibunnyx]

I have and love both! but if you have other smug villagers, choose poppy!

 

[Feunard]

I honestly like them both, I have Marshal in my town and I would like to have Poppy, too. Marshal is very nice, he always makes me laugh ! c: I don't have Poppy, but she is a normal villager, I really like her personality and she is so cute ! :3 If I were you I would keep Marshal and Poppy at the same time and keep the one you like most after a couple of weeks; but, if you want to choose now, you should keep Poppy, her personality is better than Marshal's, I think. However, they are both squirrels, the animal I like most in Animal Crossing, so, in my mind, each choice is good ! ^^

 

[Fitolink]

I see them equally cute, but I know Marshal is more popular and expensive, so that may be a good factor to keep him. And I would rather keep smug personality than normal personality. But if you decide keep Poppy, you can sell Marshal for a good amount of money, or change it for another dreamie, I think you can change it for whoever you want.

 

[Buttonsy]

You should go with who you have more attachment to, like who you think you would miss the most, but I personally prefer Poppy.

 

[AudyBanana]

Well I prefer Poppy, but go with whoever you like more!

 

[LuminousLisa]

I really love the normal villager personality, 2nd only to the lazy personality. I find a few of the smug villagers cute, but try as I might, I just can't seem to like the smug personality... They bug the crud out of me! I'm so over being told I look as cool as a fair number of cucumbers :rolling eyes:

 

[Soigne]

I adore Poppy, so I voted for her, but if you have a preference just stick with who you like more!

 

[AccfSally]

Marshal, Poppy can be a bit boring sometimes.

 

[radioloves]

Ahh I pick Marshal, smugs are one of my favorites <3