propably anicotti. i resetted my town when i got my second copy just to get her. i ended up abandoning that town, but i'd still like to have her in Ethereal some day
Elvis, he was a starter in my first ever ACNL town too, which is where I started the series. Him, Kyle, and Static are my main 3 favorites and I've never had a town without Elvis. I plan on getting him asap once I get ACNH.
Pate. She was in my first New Leaf town. She moved away back when I didn't know there was a way to be certain if anyone is moving or not.
Due to the fact that not many villagers have moved out, I can still see her at my main street. I'm happy she's still visiting... because I miss her.
My favorite starter would have to be Mira! I like her hero like design (I have a soft spot for bunny villagers) and she always gives me medicine when I get stung by bees
Probably Scoot. I can’t remember my Gamecube starters. My New Leaf starters were Scoot, Claudia, Hugh, Bubbles, and Wart Jr. I felt attachment to none of them.
Colton was my starting Smug in New Leaf and I've loved him dearly since. His princely design is 10000% my aesthetic, he's just the cutest. I literally screamed when I found him while island hopping.
On that note, Kiki was one of my starters in GCN and she's been my best buddy across every AC title I've owned. I love her so much.
Rosie and Roscoe were both OG villagers for me in my first New Leaf town and have been my favorite villagers ever since. Another original from that town is Cousteau who I feel is underrated and underappreciated!
I’d definitely say the pekoe was {and still is} my favourite villager. Both as a starter and as a villager in general. Although she looks peppy or snooty, she’s just a normal villager :]
I haven't played New Leaf in awhile, but Roscoe the horse was one of my starting villagers in the copy of New Leaf I got on the release date. He's still there! He's the only OG villager I've kept because I really love him
Rosie or Chief back in Gamecube and Wild World. That was back before I even really knew about villagers or that there were a bunch of them though. I loved both of them so much and will always have a soft spot for both of them.
My New Leaf first villager that stood out to me was Pecan. I thought she was really cute and she always gave me gifts ;w;
When I was around 5 or 6 years old, Stitches was in my first town in City Folk ! I really loved his bright colours. I also had Purrl move in a few days after starting my first town, I actually thought it was Rover at first for some reason lmao. She reminded me of my old cat !
With me it has to be Nan, it's just she always felt like an older friend that would always look out for you, check up on you and just make sure you're alright
Cherry and Jitters were my starters in my main NH island, and I love them both. But I (re)started my second island two days ago and Dom and Katt were my starters and I already love them!