Who do you think is the most underrated villager?

[MayorSammy!]

for me, its Peanut, it really shocked me that she wasn't Top Tier. She's a cutie and a real bundle of joy!

​

 

[gem83]

Winnie the peppy horse! One of my best friends has her in their town and she's such a cutie! When I first made an account here I was surprised to see that she isn't very popular!

 

[Two-Face]

I'd go with Baabara, daahling. She was my favorite villager when she was in my town.

 

[Dorian]

Mac, the jock dog. He is so wonderful that I can barely stand it

 

[almyki]

Of course I'll just choose the one from my favorites that is in bottom tier, haha. I decided Chadder was my favorite smug villager, and when I went to check his ranking, I was so surprised he didn't technically 'rank' at all! I'm really new to all this but I thought smug types and food-themed types tended to be popular, and he's cheese-themed and everything. I think his design is so cute and unique!

Well, not that I'm complaining either. I guess that means when I try to get a Chadder later, I at least won't have to worry about giving an arm and a leg for him if I try to get it online. I kind of like liking a villager that's not popular too.

Ali

 

[HungryForCereal]

i swear theres more than 10 threads asking who is the most underrated villager.

 

[Sansa]

Margie. I wouldn't expect her to be Tier 1 or 2, but I AM surprised that's she's a Tier 5! She's SO cute and nice, a white elephant with a flower on her head. :3

 

[HopeForHyrule]

for me, its Peanut, it really shocked me that she wasn't Top Tier. She's a cutie and a real bundle of joy!

View attachment 152481​

I agree with you on Peanut. She's an adorable pink squirrel! How is she not a higher tier???

Also: I love your Angel Bunny avatar! ^_^

 

[visibleghost]

ALL THE TIER FIVE FROGS (except maybe wart jr and jambette i'm sorry ;

 

[HHoney]

Margie. I wouldn't expect her to be Tier 1 or 2, but I AM surprised that's she's a Tier 5! She's SO cute and nice, a white elephant with a flower on her head. :3

AND she was basically the STAR in the Animal Crossing movie???!!!!

Tier 5? Seriously?

I had her in one of my towns and I was so thrilled when she met me at the train station!! I adore her.

 

[gem83]

HHoney has a good point. Margie WAS the star of that movie. Isn't the movie the reason why Rosie is popular? (I personally don't like Margie but wouldn't it then be logical for her to be more popular than tier 5?)

 

[Talonwhisker]

I'd say Tex; he was one of my dreamies and I was shocked to see his adorable penguin face in the bottom tier!

 

[00jachna]

Wart JR
Harry
Yuka

 

[HHoney]

I'd say Tex; he was one of my dreamies and I was shocked to see his adorable penguin face in the bottom tier!

I had Tex as my smug when I came back to ACNL earlier this year. I totally have a soft spot for him. He is an adorable penguin! Deserves to be higher.

 

[cIementine]

O'Hare and Bill. Hands down best smug and jock!

 

[Hirisa]

I'd say that technically they're all underrated, because tier lists are simplistic and reductive, and account for nothing of importance. They merely reflect the whims of the marketplace. But by that same measurement they are all also overrated!

 

[crystalchild]

olaf, obviously, how can people resist this hot anteater. it's beyond me.

 

[cIementine]

olaf, obviously, how can people resist this hot anteater. it's beyond me.

he looks like Michael jackson

 

[Kristen]

Of course I'll just choose the one from my favorites that is in bottom tier, haha. I decided Chadder was my favorite smug villager, and when I went to check his ranking, I was so surprised he didn't technically 'rank' at all! I'm really new to all this but I thought smug types and food-themed types tended to be popular, and he's cheese-themed and everything. I think his design is so cute and unique!

Well, not that I'm complaining either. I guess that means when I try to get a Chadder later, I at least won't have to worry about giving an arm and a leg for him if I try to get it online. I kind of like liking a villager that's not popular too.

Ali

I've seen a lot of people who love Chadder, so I'm surprised that he's not higher up in the list.

Margie. I wouldn't expect her to be Tier 1 or 2, but I AM surprised that's she's a Tier 5! She's SO cute and nice, a white elephant with a flower on her head. :3

She's ultra cute and I have to say the same thing about her as I did Chadder!

I feel like there should be more tiers but it's a lot of work to sort that out.

 

[okaimii]

Filbert! I was so surprised when I found out that he wasn't in the top tiers. He's super cute!