Whitney or Colton

[RoyalPain]

Hello everyone I previously created a thread where I needed to figure out what villagers fit into my elegant themed town. I’ve figured out my dreamies (Marshal, Stitches, Diana, Zucker, Marina, Pietro, Chrissy, Francine, Julian). Now I’m stumped between Whitney and Colton. Idk which one seeing as how they both fit excellent into my town. Please let me know which you all think, thanks ^_^

 

[Dracyoshi]

Personally, I prefer the design of Whitney. But keep in mind that Whitney is one of the most popular villagers, so Colton would be a more unique and original choice! If that doesn't matter, I think you should go for Whitney. If not, go for Colton!

Also, if you're plotting out where villagers will move into then you could also choose them by their house design! Choose the house design that fits best. Here's a link to Colton's house, and here's a link to Whitney's house. Credit to aforestlife.

 

[Flare]

From these two I'd probably pick Whitney.

 

[LadyDestani]

I agree that either would fit your theme, but my personal favorite would be Colton.

I looked at your personality split to see if that made a difference, but it looks like you have 2 of each, snooty and smug, already. So, you're not lacking in either. Keep in mind that you'll end up with 3 of the same personality of whichever one you choose. So if you favor one personality over the other, that may be the way to go.

Either way, you can't go wrong, though.

 

[PrincessAurora]

Whitney would be my choice. But I might be slightly biased. c:

 

[xSuperMario64x]

WHITNEY IS SO PRECIOUS OMG

Also she would definitely fit in with an elegant theme, so she s the obvious choice here

 

[RoyalPain]

Thank you all this made it easier for my decision, I think I’m gonna go with Whitney, I’ve never had a wolf in my town before so it’ll be a nice change ^_^. I’m not gonna close this thread yet in case I change my mind.

 

[HistoryH22]

I'll pile on the Whitney side. I've been loving her in my own town!

 

[hotskittlss]

I may be biased, but pick colton! he's really dorky and cute. I haven't gotten to know Whitney yet since ive never gotten her, but im sure she's very nice too qwq;;

 

[Kub]

Whitney is super popular but Colton is such a gem <3 you’d be lucky to have him in your town!!!!

 

[RoyalPain]

Ohmigosh thank you all soo much, funny thing but I’m actually gonna go with both of them, I’ve decided I don’t really want Marina anymore doing a little research I learned people ship Colton and Julien so I gotta put them both together. Thanks again everyone ^_^

 

[AlyssaAC]

I would choose Whitney as I really like the wolf villagers, but Colton isn't too bad either.

 

[LaFra]

Whitney without a doubt in my case. I don't really like horses in AC.

EDIT:

Ohmigosh thank you all soo much, funny thing but I’m actually gonna go with both of them, I’ve decided I don’t really want Marina anymore doing a little research I learned people ship Colton and Julien so I gotta put them both together. Thanks again everyone ^_^

Oh ,well... happy ending for both? xD

 

[FoxFeathers]

Out of those, Colton would be my choice. He looks more interesting to me.

 

[Croconaw]

Colton hands down

 

[Korichi]

Ohmigosh thank you all soo much, funny thing but I’m actually gonna go with both of them, I’ve decided I don’t really want Marina anymore doing a little research I learned people ship Colton and Julien so I gotta put them both together. Thanks again everyone ^_^

Ah, congratulations on getting both!! They’re both equally great matches for an elegant town so I’m glad it all worked out! And it’s also so cute that you put Colton and Julian together ;7;

 

[Mr_Persona]

Ohmigosh thank you all soo much, funny thing but I’m actually gonna go with both of them, I’ve decided I don’t really want Marina anymore doing a little research I learned people ship Colton and Julien so I gotta put them both together. Thanks again everyone ^_^

great choice cause idk who to pick for your town
I love them both

 

[Static_Luver]

Personally, I'd choose Whitney.

 

[fiirefly-crossing]

I like both characters, but if i had to choose i would choose Whitney. Had her in my town previously and she was a delight!

 

[hamster]

im not really a fan of both but i like whitney a lot more