I like all of my villager but since its easier to plot reset with the use of paths I kinda want to switch some around. I never want to get rid of Hamphrey and Vesta though.
Sally, Katt, Friga, Iggly, Tom and Anabelle are my permies but Sally is definitely my fav of all time so I'd probably delete my town if she ever were to leave.
I plan on keeping Celia, Rolf, Tybalt, Deli, Wolfgang and Fang forever (though I have to move Fang out first, then 16 villager cycle to move him back in so I can plot him in a better spot). I really like Whitney & Mitzi, but their presence isn't consistent enough, so sometimes I have the urge to let them go because I hardly see them. It depends, though. So far they've been sticking around.
My 2nd town is new, so I'm not too attached to anyone yet. But I feel like Tutu will stick around for a very long time at least.
Peanut is my oldest villager being with me since 2013
I always let go villagers when they want to move but she for some reason never made pings about moving O_O so it's destiny I guess... she will be with me forever ever if one day she will ping that will the only time that I will answer no
I go by a dreamie system, so Marshal, Diana, Cookie, Merengue, Beau, Willow, Poppy, Mint, and Maple are never leaving Heaven.
Moonview only has a few dreamies set for it though; Bunnie, Katt, Static, and Olivia are not leaving anytime soon.
Well, i hope no one in my town leaves because i FINALLY got it where i love every villager. I want Kyle and Whitney, Drago, Tia, and Moe to stay put. Those guys arent amiibo and i cant find (affordable) cards for them. Lyman, however, must always stay. But seriously, if Moe ever leaves ill cry. Hes been with me since 2013.