Which to get rid of?

[Elise]

I voted Vesta without reading, oops. She's the one I would personally get rid of, just because I'm not really a fan of the sheep.

Having actually read the post, I would say Rosie. If you are not attached to her she will be much easier for you to let go of than the others who you seem to actually like a lot more. I hate to say this though, as I am a huge fan of Rosie and don't understand how anyone wouldn't love her too

 

[Selky]

Rosie....she's really kind of the least attractive cat imo or peppy but to each their own.
Tia is amazing and Flora would be second best for me.

 

[Cou]

Vesta.

Flora is so cute too cute to get rid of, I have Rosie but I prefer to have Flora as my Peppy.
Rosie is also a good peppy, but yeah I'd still prefer Flora, if you don't mind having two peppies, Rosie is another good villager to keep.
And Tia is one of the cutest normal villagers ever. I had her but had to move her out because I had to choose between who to keep as well, it was between her, Merengue, Marshal, and Julian. And yeah, the cuteness was just too much but I prefer Smugs over Normal (especially because Marshal and Julian were like my boyfriends// the flirt with me a lot LOL), and Merengue is a cute shortcake as Tia is a cute teapot so I was so confused, but since my friend wanted Tia, I just gave her to him. And yeah, it's really up to you who you're willing to give up. ^_^ They're all lovely, and I admit, Vesta is one of the cutest sheeps ever. And since you're attached to her, man it'll be hard to let go. I also regret letting go of my first villagers

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Get rid of Vesta. I don't like her at all.
The other villagers are awesome.

 

[PurplPanda]

For your lazy and snooty get Stitches and Tiffany and kick everyone else out and have a town full of lazies and snooties bc they are my favorites.

 

[Waluigi]

Get rid of tia. Shes really ugly, and vesta is a much better normal

 

[Gummysaur]

Get rid of Rosie and make moolah off her.

 

[Yui Z]

I'd say Vesta (even though Vesta is a cutie still<3)

 

[dreamysnowx]

Vesta, change is what livens up your town. Although she's been with you since the start, I suggest that it's time you let her go to experience a new villager. I had to make this hard decision when moving out one of my starter villagers. :~)

 

[PockiPops]

It sounds as if you like Rosie the least. :3

 

[Summ3rain]

Rosie is cute but I had her and she never grew on me so I let her go... Never had Vesta so cant comment but I love most of the sheep love flora and Tia... So I say let Rosie go

 

[lilyandemrys]

Oooooooooooooooooh, tricky one.

I'd probably say Vesta.

 

[Bearica]

I'd say either Rosie or Vesta since you dont seem attached to either.

 

[oath2order]

Tia sux