Which one of my villagers is the weakest link?

[silver_shroud]

I'm interested in getting some opinions on which villager I should send packing next in order to pursue my next dreamie. Purely subjective of course, but I think it could be helpful to get some other viewpoints! My current villagers are:

Marshal
Julian
Tia
Drago
Bam
Cookie
Fuchsia
Elvis
Alice
Freya

What do you guys think? (If anyone else if facing a similar conundrum, post yours too!)

 

[Ami Mercury]

Marshal.....NOW BEFORE PEOPLE START HOUNDING ME FOR SAYING THAT, I AM ANSWERING A QUESTION HERE!

Elvis and Drago are IMO your best villagers!

 

[PopteenPrincess]

Alice. I don't like her all that much :/

 

[dizzy bone]

Maybe get rid of one of the snooties or smugs since you have two (I'd get rid of Julian or Fuchsia). I don't particularly like Cookie or Alice either. I like Elvis out of all your villagers :3

 

[Ami Mercury]

Maybe get rid of one of the snooties or smugs since you have two (I'd get rid of Julian or Fuchsia). I don't particularly like Cookie or Alice either. I like Elvis out of all your villagers :3

Love Elvis he is my 19th favorite

 

[silver_shroud]

I'm so glad to see all this Elvis love, was not expecting that! He has turned out to be an unexpected favorite of mine as well, certainly my favorite cranky villager

 

[Ami Mercury]

I'm so glad to see all this Elvis love, was not expecting that! He has turned out to be an unexpected favorite of mine as well, certainly my favorite cranky villager

What's not to love about him. He's a lion!!!! That's why we like him!

 

[silver_shroud]

What's not to love about him. He's a lion!!!! That's why we like him!

And the scar makes him a total bad boy -- he's the real deal for sure!

 

[Rozart]

I don't know how attached you are to some of your villagers but I never really got attached to Cookie. She's a pretty 'meh' villager to me. And I always found Fuchsia's colour scheme too be a little much. She's pretty but those clashing colours... :S

What's the personality type of your next dreamie? I think that'll help you narrow down which ones you should let go-- especially if you're not fond of having too many villagers of the same personality type.

 

[Fairy]

Drago.

 

[silver_shroud]

I don't know how attached you are to some of your villagers but I never really got attached to Cookie. She's a pretty 'meh' villager to me. And I always found Fuchsia's colour scheme too be a little much. She's pretty but those clashing colours... :S

What's the personality type of your next dreamie? I think that'll help you narrow down which ones you should let go-- especially if you're not fond of having too many villagers of the same personality type.

I am rather attached to Cookie, so I don't see myself letting her go anytime soon. Fuchsia was an early favorite, but I have had her in my village since the beginning...

My next dreamie is a lazy personality (Stitches!) but I'm not too bothered about having multiples of the same type

 

[Lurrdoc]

Alice, Cookie or Elvis. The other villagers are reasonably sought after and you should keep them in case you wanna' trade 'em for dreamies or sell 'em.

 

[silver_shroud]

I've definitely been leaning toward Alice, and that seems to be the general consensus. Thinking that her days in my town are numbered!

 

[LinDUNguin]

Freya, but I have a terrible experience with Freya. I'd say either her or Alice, just because Alice fits a more beach type theme where the others are either neutral or fit a theme with one another. I do quite like Alice though

 

[nekosync]

They all seem okay to me.

 

[franzi]

I'd definitely let Alice go;s

 

[yosugay]

julian. he scares me

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Alice. I don't like her so much. Your other villagers are way better.
Good luck.

 

[SliceAndDice]

Either Marshal or Alice. Marhal because you have two smugs and I prefer Julian over him and Alice because I really don't like her design. :| Elivs is cool though. He looks like the king of lions.

 

[Candy83]

GUIDELINE: Villager Personalities Criteria

? Males ?
1 Cranky
1 Jock
1 Lazy
1 Smug​

? Females ?
1 Snooty
1 Peppy
1 Normal
1 Uchi​

For the two remaining, choose one more male (from preferred category) and one more female (from preferred category).