-
The results of the egg decorating contest have been announced! Everyone's designs were amazing! Congratulations to our winners!
Which of my towns is best?
- Thread starter marylu
- Start date
When I get home tonight I'll try to remember to visit both towns!
thanks!
TheGreatBrain
Senior Member
Town of Fantasia.
You have some areas of your town that are absolutly gorgeous.Like the flower clock, flower beds, ect.Love your forest, face standee and zen area.
The main room in your house is so cute, You added just the right amount of pink.I like that you have a back yard.I'm not a fan of pave, but you made it look nice.Great job on the kitchen.
Town of Fandango.
I like your road path.This town is very nice, but it's just not as stunning as Fantasia.I really like how you decorated your house, but once again, This one didn't impress me as much.Fantasa's house seemed a bit more girly while Fandango's was more guyish.lol.Not that it matters, just thought I would mention that.
Overall, Both towns were a joy to visit, but Fantasia was my fave.
I have two towns also.Would you mind telling me which one you like best? My towns are nice, but it's the houses I'm more proud of.
You have some areas of your town that are absolutly gorgeous.Like the flower clock, flower beds, ect.Love your forest, face standee and zen area.
The main room in your house is so cute, You added just the right amount of pink.I like that you have a back yard.I'm not a fan of pave, but you made it look nice.Great job on the kitchen.
Town of Fandango.
I like your road path.This town is very nice, but it's just not as stunning as Fantasia.I really like how you decorated your house, but once again, This one didn't impress me as much.Fantasa's house seemed a bit more girly while Fandango's was more guyish.lol.Not that it matters, just thought I would mention that.
Overall, Both towns were a joy to visit, but Fantasia was my fave.
I have two towns also.Would you mind telling me which one you like best? My towns are nice, but it's the houses I'm more proud of.
MightyMunchlax
Senior Member
I'll visit them and give you feedback about both then decide at the end.
~Fantasia~
Rather than putting fruit by your tree for guests might I suggest streetpass items or other fun things you can interact with in the game? I know these are a bit tricky to come by. Just a suggestion I like when people leave me things to have. Even coffee from the cafe is nice.
I like the path you've chosen though it's nice.
Maybe it's just cause I'm OCD but some areas I feel need to be connected. Or maybe I'm just not a fan of the "natural" path where you run and make your grass die. I like things to be connected. Like by the fire pit thing I felt it was kind of out of the way.
But you have some really nice areas:
I went into your mayor's house as well. I tend to only really rate the mayor's house cause it's usually the one you've developed the most. I must say I like how you've blended a lot of different sets together to create a unique space. My first thought upon entering was "This room is very psychedelic." But in a good way. If that makes sense.
Overall you've done a good job putting your town together it looks nice. Maybe I just don't like the worn in path idea cause I'm very OCD and things have to match and connect. (if you ever go to my DA you'll see what I mean. I need to update it again.) But I enjoyed it!
+Fandango+
I think your tree plaza area could use a bit more decorating around it. I like your street path though I want to do something similar on my cycling.
You have some interesting villagers, definitely not ones you see everyday, but variety is never a bad thing so long as you are content with them. That's how I feel about villagers in general. Villagers get a lot of flack for their tier ranking, but overall if a villager makes you happy who am I to judge.
But Mira though:
I miss her.
Anyways the area below the plaza I didn't quite understand. It seemed out of place to me.
I like this area, mostly cause I didn't have a lot of room by my town hall to do things (*cough Felicity*). Also photobomb Cranston:
I like this little feature
Don't know what purpose this serves with the theme of your town
There are a few areas that are underdeveloped I feel.
And your mayor's house was alright. Nothing too spectacular. The side room was very green..Not saying it's a bad thing just observing.
Overall it's nice, but it still needs some work. Keep at it. Hope this was helpful!
Just for overall development I'm gonna go with Fantasia as the winner. :3 (Sorry it's long)
~Fantasia~
Rather than putting fruit by your tree for guests might I suggest streetpass items or other fun things you can interact with in the game? I know these are a bit tricky to come by. Just a suggestion I like when people leave me things to have. Even coffee from the cafe is nice.
I like the path you've chosen though it's nice.
Maybe it's just cause I'm OCD but some areas I feel need to be connected. Or maybe I'm just not a fan of the "natural" path where you run and make your grass die. I like things to be connected. Like by the fire pit thing I felt it was kind of out of the way.
But you have some really nice areas:
I went into your mayor's house as well. I tend to only really rate the mayor's house cause it's usually the one you've developed the most. I must say I like how you've blended a lot of different sets together to create a unique space. My first thought upon entering was "This room is very psychedelic." But in a good way. If that makes sense.
View attachment 52572
I liked this side room I thought it was very nicely done. I've never been a fan of the green furniture, but I like it this way.
View attachment 52573
This room just made me hungry...
View attachment 52574
I liked this side room I thought it was very nicely done. I've never been a fan of the green furniture, but I like it this way.
View attachment 52573
This room just made me hungry...
View attachment 52574
Overall you've done a good job putting your town together it looks nice. Maybe I just don't like the worn in path idea cause I'm very OCD and things have to match and connect. (if you ever go to my DA you'll see what I mean. I need to update it again.) But I enjoyed it!
+Fandango+
I think your tree plaza area could use a bit more decorating around it. I like your street path though I want to do something similar on my cycling.
You have some interesting villagers, definitely not ones you see everyday, but variety is never a bad thing so long as you are content with them. That's how I feel about villagers in general. Villagers get a lot of flack for their tier ranking, but overall if a villager makes you happy who am I to judge.
But Mira though:
I miss her.
Anyways the area below the plaza I didn't quite understand. It seemed out of place to me.
I like this area, mostly cause I didn't have a lot of room by my town hall to do things (*cough Felicity*). Also photobomb Cranston:
I like this little feature
Don't know what purpose this serves with the theme of your town
There are a few areas that are underdeveloped I feel.
And your mayor's house was alright. Nothing too spectacular. The side room was very green..Not saying it's a bad thing just observing.
Overall it's nice, but it still needs some work. Keep at it. Hope this was helpful!
Just for overall development I'm gonna go with Fantasia as the winner. :3 (Sorry it's long)
Last edited:
Thank you for your feedback, the mayor's house in fandango is supposed to be guyish by the way, but i haven't put that much of an effort in decorating it yet. I visited your towns and this is what I thought:
JOY: it is very cool all the themes you have done with it, great job with the garden near Cinderella's castle, also the pumpkins design with the scarecrow are a nice addition to your fall season. Snow White was my favorite house, loved how you put a mine room and the 7 dwarfs room. Also Cinderella castle looks great on the outside and the wedding scene is really nice with the stained glass detail on the wall. Your Santa house was great also, I thought the toy workshop was a innovative room, nice idea. The witch's house is creepy, but of course that's the idea, great rooms here with the potion making and the monsters party is really fun looking, didn't expect that.
Farmland: I really liked the brick pattern you used on the town, I thought maybe you needed more variety in the pwp used. The houses are also great here, my favorite was old Mcdonald, your cow room is pretty cool and the outdoors farm is also nice. The wool house i enjoyed as well, it is great how you had the room with the sheep, the sewing room and the shop.
I really enjoyed your towns, my vote goes to JOY, overall thought it had better looking spots in town and the houses were pretty awesome.
- - - Post Merge - - -
MightyMunchlax, thank you for your feedback and for taking some time to post pictures. I know what you mean with the fandango underdeveloped areas, I'm actually planning on putting something there but don't have the pwp requested yet. I visited your town, It was really great the way you used paths, maybe it is because you haven't updated it yet, but seemed like the bottom right of your town needed more work. I enjoyed visiting.
MightyMunchlax
Senior Member
Yeah I haven't updated it yet, I've actually been working on that area it was a hybrid breeding ground for a while. I've added a lot since I last updated, I'm just waiting on bushes and trees to grow now before I update again.
Edit: boo, my links aren't working which is weird cause I uploaded them from my computer...
Edit: boo, my links aren't working which is weird cause I uploaded them from my computer...
Last edited:
trickypitfall
=======
Oh man, I'll have to visit your towns now because I can't see all of the attached images and now I'm really curious.
------
Fantas?a:
Ahh this town is so pretty and peaceful, like GreatBrain said the zen and clock areas were really nice. Though I did think that the flowers got to be a little muddled sometimes? (That might just be because I'm not a big fan of yellow roses.) I did also think that your path decisions were a little strange sometimes. The main one you're using is really nice but the brick pattern kind of stuck out to me? It cut into your normal path in odd spots sometimes. (Like around villager houses)
But your houses were really lovely! I can tell you put a lot of effort into them. (I especially liked the cafe and kitchen your Mayor's house had.)
Fandago:
I agree that some of Fandango seemed underdeveloped, but the zen garden/scarecrow part were really cute. I think they were my favorite tbh. The path is a lot more organized than in Fandango... I think the brick actually went really well with the road pattern you're using.
Again the house was really nicely done. I appreciate that you mix furniture rather than use all of one set. It makes rooms more interesting.
All in all both of your towns really lovely, I think I might prefer Fantas?a a teeny bit more though.
------
Fantas?a:
Ahh this town is so pretty and peaceful, like GreatBrain said the zen and clock areas were really nice. Though I did think that the flowers got to be a little muddled sometimes? (That might just be because I'm not a big fan of yellow roses.) I did also think that your path decisions were a little strange sometimes. The main one you're using is really nice but the brick pattern kind of stuck out to me? It cut into your normal path in odd spots sometimes. (Like around villager houses)
But your houses were really lovely! I can tell you put a lot of effort into them. (I especially liked the cafe and kitchen your Mayor's house had.)
Fandago:
I agree that some of Fandango seemed underdeveloped, but the zen garden/scarecrow part were really cute. I think they were my favorite tbh. The path is a lot more organized than in Fandango... I think the brick actually went really well with the road pattern you're using.
Again the house was really nicely done. I appreciate that you mix furniture rather than use all of one set. It makes rooms more interesting.
All in all both of your towns really lovely, I think I might prefer Fantas?a a teeny bit more though.
Last edited:
Similar threads
