When you really want to invite another villager in, but don’t wanna kick out anyone!

[Candyapple]

I?m sure everyone had this problem atleast once.
You have all your favorite villagers. It?s all good, you obtained some of them from other players, some were just there from the start of your town. BUT!!! You have some amiibo cards sitting there in your house. And you remember a few of them are of your dear villagers that you had in almost all AC games...
In my case, it?s Kiki.
I even forgot about Kiki for a while. I have my NL town, Gelato, that?s going really good and has a good mix of all personalities.
Then, I look at the Halloween event and I see the battle between villagers. And I see Kiki!
Kiki, my dear black kitty that reminds me so much of my real life old cat!
Kiki, that was a villager in one of my previous towns that I resetted. I love Kiki and now I?d like to invite her to Gelato but...who would I kick??
I can?t kick anyone!!
Help! I know each of you will have different opinions on who to keep and who to kick, but I can?t really decide.
My current villagers are:

1.T-Bone. I got him from someone in this forum for free, otherwise he would have been voided. I love him and he?s the only cranky of my town!
2. Merry. The only peppy. She was in Gelato since the very beginning! She?s adorable and funny.
3. Vesta. No way I would ever get rid of her. She?s pretty unique even if I have 2 more normal personalities in my town beside her. I got her from a forum user!
4.Bones. I have one more lazy in town. I had Bones in my wild world town as well, and loved him and I lost him already once and I felt sad for days. I got him from someone on the forum!
5.Chester: he?s the second lazy. He?s been there since the start of this town! I love him cause he?s creepy but cute and gentle, and I love his unique look.
6. Alli. I like her she has pretty colors, but she?s the only snooty in my town! If I get rid of her, no more of that type will live in Gelato :/
7. Dora, another normal personality that I moved in my town cause I have her card. I love her cause she was one of my best friends in my ACWW town, along with Bones.
8. Norma. A pink and light blue cow that has a dairy shop in her house! What?s not to love about her? She also has pigtails and a friendly face! I love Norma even if she?s the 3rd normal of my town.
9. Marshal. The only kind I have with this personality. I moved him in cause I have his card and he?s just adorable!
10. Fuchsia. I really like her colors and she?s the only uchi I have. I got her from someone on the forum and I like her a lot!

Can you help me decide who to kick to make space for my dear Kiki?? Thank you for reading all this long post xD you?re awesome

 

[-Blue-]

Do you only have one game? Cause if you have a second you could invite her there. I don't really like the idea of having others tell you who to can. I read all those names up there and some I recognize and some I never had. They don't mean anything to me. The villagers I have or still do meant more because they came from my town.

 

[Candyapple]

Do you only have one game? Cause if you have a second you could invite her there. I don't really like the idea of having others tell you who to can. I read all those names up there and some I recognize and some I never had. They don't mean anything to me. The villagers I have or still do meant more because they came from my town.

No I don’t have any other game :/ I was just asking for some advice to help me clear up my mind, the truth is this game has so many awesome villagers and we have to settle for 10... it’s alwsys going to be a pain xD so I realize why people would buy more then only one cartridge. But in my case, I like the idea of taking care of only one town, more it would be too much for me and I wouldn’t want to see another town being neglected... cause I don’t have enough time :/

 

[-Blue-]

Well if you throw Kiki in the mix and keep all your normals that will be four normals altogether. Trust me on that, it will get old. I had three peppys at one time. One day I talked to each of them, right after the other, and they all said the same dialogue from start to end.

I threw me out of the game I was immersed in. So I'd say if you really really want Kiki you should probably cut back on the normals. Swap one of them out for her. That's up to you though.

 

[AlyssaAC]

Well if you throw Kiki in the mix and keep all your normals that will be four normals altogether. Trust me on that, it will get old. I had three peppys at one time. One day I talked to each of them, right after the other, and they all said the same dialogue from start to end.

I threw me out of the game I was immersed in. So I'd say if you really really want Kiki you should probably cut back on the normals. Swap one of them out for her. That's up to you though.

I agree with this one. Having too many of the same personality can get pretty old pretty fast. Whenever I replace someone in my town, I usually replace the villager with the same personality. I like to keep different personalities in my town because it makes life in my town interesting.

 

[Candyapple]

I agree with this one. Having too many of the same personality can get pretty old pretty fast. Whenever I replace someone in my town, I usually replace the villager with the same personality. I like to keep different personalities in my town because it makes life in my town interesting.

Yea I’m thinking about that now. I always do the mistake to invite too many normal villagers, cause I like so many of them. But like you said, it gets old when you’re talking to someone and it’s the exact same dialogue you heard from the other 2, over and over! I’ll have to make sure I find a good home for the normal villager I’m going to replace!

 

[esweeeny]

I'd suggest since Kiki is normal, pick one of the normals to kick out unfortantely! :/

Now who to choose that's a different story.

 

[Sothe]

I would definitely not kick out anyone who’s the only one of a personality type, unless you got all the PWPs you like from them. Like everyone else I would suggest getting rid of one of the normals, but preference-wise just boils down to you. I would also maybe recommend maybe getting rid of one of either Bones or Chester since you’ll still have a lazy villager in your town.

It seems like you’re definitely not getting rid of Vesta, so it looks like either Norma or Dora or one of Bones/Chester.

I’d probably get rid of Chester but that’s just my personal preference.

 

[Candyapple]

I'd suggest since Kiki is normal, pick one of the normals to kick out unfortantely! :/

Now who to choose that's a different story.

Yes seems like the most logic option. It’s going to take a while to decide who between the normals, though ^_^;

I would definitely not kick out anyone who’s the only one of a personality type, unless you got all the PWPs you like from them. Like everyone else I would suggest getting rid of one of the normals, but preference-wise just boils down to you. I would also maybe recommend maybe getting rid of one of either Bones or Chester since you’ll still have a lazy villager in your town.

It seems like you’re definitely not getting rid of Vesta, so it looks like either Norma or Dora or one of Bones/Chester.

I’d probably get rid of Chester but that’s just my personal preference.

Yes, now everything is more clear to me and I think I’ll get rid of one of the normal villagers. True I could kick Bones or Chester too, but Bones is one of my oldest friends in my very first villages and Chester is one of the first to wear my custom design xD and... this might sound stupid but he sent me a letter that said “I had a nightmare that you disappeared from our town. Please promise me
you’ll never leave our town!” I know it’s funny but I got attached to this little creepy panda bear!

This game I swear...it’s kinda magic! How we can get attached to these pixelated little characters, haha!!

 

[esweeeny]

I know right? I check on my squirrels everyday and am seriously attached to them!!

The game makes me so happy though =)

Right, Chester is a super great Lazy and so is Bones. Decisions decisions. This is why we should be able to have more villagers in town. That would solve a lot of problems haha

I wanted to include callie and agent S in my town, too but there were only 10 squirrels I could choose from lol.

 

[LaFra]

Kick the sheep!
In my opinion is the best compromise if you want to hug Kiki again.
I'm the only one who thinks Chester is really cute and the facial expressions reminds me Great Teacher Onizuka?

 

[Candyapple]

I know right? I check on my squirrels everyday and am seriously attached to them!!

The game makes me so happy though =)

Right, Chester is a super great Lazy and so is Bones. Decisions decisions. This is why we should be able to have more villagers in town. That would solve a lot of problems haha

I wanted to include callie and agent S in my town, too but there were only 10 squirrels I could choose from lol.

Oh yes squirrels I love them too! I had Callie and Sylvana in my old towns. So much cuteness!! In my opinion Callie is very underrated. No one ever talks about her but she?s adorable and her house is so pretty inside. I totally agree with you ^_^ this game makes me joyful everytime I log into my little happy village ^__^

Kick the sheep!
In my opinion is the best compromise if you want to hug Kiki again.
I'm the only one who thinks Chester is really cute and the facial expressions reminds me Great Teacher Onizuka?

Hey Fra!!
Oh believe me I love Chester too! He?s very different from other pandas and especially different from other panda in the game. He?s a little ball of creepy cuteness!
But Fra... kicking the poor sheep? Vesta is very cute, she looks like if a drawing from a little children came to life

 

[LaFra]

Look at her:

Spoiler

Vesta is like a monster... these light neon eyes and mouth, she is kinda creepy. D:
She can eat you while you sleep.

Ok, i'm joking... xd Vesta is not a ugly villager but not even the most pretty.

 

[Candyapple]

Look at her:

Spoiler

Vesta is like a monster... these light neon eyes and mouth, she is kinda creepy. D:
She can eat you while you sleep.

Hahahahaha!!! But Fra... she just wants some love! She’s kinda creepy for sure, but I love creepy characters. Like Coco too!

 

[LaFra]

I like Coco (the concept) but is not a villager I'd like to have in a town, too much "weird"...

IMHO The other thing you can do is "switch" Dora with Kiki, you can always make moving their with the cards, right?
I know you love Dora, but mice in AC are... ouch

 

[Candyapple]

That’s true. I could switch Dora cause having her card means I can always have her in my town when I want. About mice, I don’t like all of them in game, but Dora yes! She’s cool cause she reminds me something from my childhood. When I was about 5 years old, in my area they used to say to children that when you lose a tooth a magical mouse comes to bring you a gift and a letter ^^ so as a child, when I lost my first tooth my mom wrote a letter for me to the magical mouse and i got a response from it the morning after! A colorful letter with a little toy and the picture of a little cute white mouse xD so to me Dora is like childhood sweet memories haha! Nice story right?

 

[LaFra]

Really heartwarming story!
At this point, KiKi can only stay in you heart... In ACNL the destiny has decided.

Let's hope for ac nintendo switch ^^

 

[-Blue-]

What kind of letters did the mice write you?

 

[Candyapple]

What kind of letters did the mice write you?

My mom at that time had a lot of imagination so everytime I lost a tooth, I would receive these cute letters with drawings of the little mouse home, of his family, of his favorite foods and things like that. When I learned how to read the letters were simple telling me little stories of this mouse that was living in this world called Fantasilandia

 

[-Blue-]

That's awesome! I hope you've at least kept one of those letters. You can maybe even do the same with your own kids. When and if that time ever comes.