In the original tier list Melba was tier 3 which I think was fair as Melba is super cute but kinda basic. She’s a koala which is cute and she’s probably one of the best koalas out there. However now she’s ended up dropping to like tier 4 which is sad because at one point she was tier 2 in new leaf so what do you think about Melba? Do you think she deserves to be a higher tier?
What’s everyone’s opinions of melba?
- Thread starter BluePing
- Start date
Melba is a villager I've always wanted and I was so excited to find her in one of my first mystery islands in New Horizons. I am finding her a little bit bland now though. Not sure if I'm just getting all the most boring normal villager dialogue bits every time I talk to her or what. Still think she's super cute though.
LittleMissPanda
💗 in the pink 💗
Melba was my first normal villager ever, since my first AC game was WW. She's fantastic! Super cute and definitely one of the best koalas!
MELBA IS SO CUTE, and basically the only Koala I actually like. Alice is okay too but I'm not big on the Koalas. Melba is super precious though and lives in my girlfriend's town, and every time I see her when I visit her town I'm like MELBAAA
Paperboy012305
Male Villager for Mario Kart World!
I kinda find her to be uninteresting for my tastes. She isn't ugly, but not cute enough for me.
naho_orange07
Carefree Wallflower
I found her on the mystery island, I thought she was so adorable! She’s a sweetie for sure. I’m just not sure if I’ll keep her forever though but I do plan to keep her for a while.
Yeah I found her today and I took her and I think she’s super cute and underrated
Post automatically merged:
She is so cute, in new leaf, her, fauna and lily were my favouritesShe's cute.
I'd say be happy her popularity has slipped. It'll make her easier to get hold of.
Post automatically merged:
Same, she’s the best koala without a doubt
Post automatically merged:
Yeah she does seem really cute, her and Ozzie are my favourites
Post automatically merged:
Yeah she’s cute but I see what you mean as she’s kinda basic but then again I find her adorable
Post automatically merged:
She is super cute and the normals are always kind and your profile pic
Post automatically merged:
She is realllyyyyy cute
Last edited:
Paperboy012305
Male Villager for Mario Kart World!
Yeah, kinda obvious that i'm not a fan of "Natural looking" villagers.
When I first saw her she seemed basic but I think she’s cute and I wanna get to know her I think
Post automatically merged:
Yeah I feel the same, when I get her I’ll just keep her for a while, kinda going for an all horse theme lol
Post automatically merged:
Yeah natural is okay but I could see how it could get boring but then again I love them all lol
