So, working on average:
Wolfgang: 2
Chrissy: 2
Francine: 2
Marshal: 2
Merengue:1
Zucker:1
Lolly: 1
1.6
I still can't see how Chrissy, Francine, and Marshal (and Julian) aren't Tier 1... I see them all the time everywhere, but I guess that's just my experience...?
Mine are
Erik: 2
Skye: 2
Pietro: 2
Bunnie: 2
Ruby: 3
Apple: 4
Benjamin: 4
Nan: 5
Kidd: 5
Rodney: 5
Which brings me to... 34 (saddening as I thought my town was super cute, but I guess that's just me.

).
To be honest I feel like the ones I like most are in the middle (Bunnie, Apple, Ruby) while my other favorites (Kidd and Nan) rank super low... the ones I don't like as much in my village (Erik and Skye... who I still love but if I had to rank them...) are the most popular villagers I have... which in a way makes sense but in another way is strange. I adore all of my villagers, the ones that I worked super hard to get are Erik, Skye, and Pietro... who are the most popular in my town, sure... but it's not like I set out to get them specifically. I only settled on getting them after resetting for cute villagers a lot, I was super lucky with Ruby (who was a starter), Apple (random move in), and in a way Bunnie (my friend let her move out of her town and let me adopt her into mine). Kidd just happened to move in one day and then he REALLY grew on me, to the point where he's now one of my absolute favorites, Nan was a villager who was camping in my town and I was really tired of restarting the day to get a new villager in my campsite so I just settled for her... but then I came to really really adore her... Benjamin was a starter and Rodney was the same deal as Nan, but I found him super adorable so I convinced him to move in (which took over a couple of hours of playing games with him). owo;
I don't really understand the tier system, because I see a lot of super adorable villagers mixed everywhere (Ruby, Filbert, Bluebear, Apple, Kiki, Lily) and some of the ones I don't care for and never see being talked about somehow rank super high... oh well. ^^;