What should I do?

[Ami Mercury]

Instead of selling him I am probably going to just trade him for Savannah.

 

[LyraVale]

If you have Marshal, you can get ANYTHING you want in the game. I'm sure you already know this. But it's worth reminding you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm also curious why you HATE him so much. I can see if you don't LOVE him, but he's pretty harmless. I mean he's cute, and he has a sweet personality. Worst thing he could do to you, is if you don't find him charming, he might bore you for a while til he leaves.

I wonder why you HATE him. Is it because others love him, and so it bothers you to look at him? In that case, I would suggest not letting him into your life. The game is supposed to be fun, and Lucky is adorable, but you can always adopt him from someone else. I'd need to know the reason you hate poor Marshmallow so much. :c

 

[Mimi14]

i have pekoe if you want to trade her for marshall?
----------
If you would like to trade could you PM me? Otherwise its okie ^^ I dont check this board often enough ;_;

 

[Ami Mercury]

If you have Marshal, you can get ANYTHING you want in the game. I'm sure you already know this. But it's worth reminding you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm also curious why you HATE him so much. I can see if you don't LOVE him, but he's pretty harmless. I mean he's cute, and he has a sweet personality. Worst thing he could do to you, is if you don't find him charming, he might bore you for a while til he leaves.

I wonder why you HATE him. Is it because others love him, and so it bothers you to look at him? In that case, I would suggest not letting him into your life. The game is supposed to be fun, and Lucky is adorable, but you can always adopt him from someone else. I'd need to know the reason you hate poor Marshmallow so much. :c

He is just a very VERY generic 'cute villager with nothing special'. He doesn't have any of the appeal that Hopper, Hans, Mira, Tucker, Ankha, Julain, Drago, Stitches, Savannah, Merengue, Clay, Pekoe, etc. have because they have things about them that make them special and unique.

 

[Ankhes]

He is just a very VERY generic 'cute villager with nothing special'. He doesn't have any of the appeal that Hopper, Hans, Mira, Tucker, Ankha, Julain, Drago, Stitches, Savannah, Merengue, Clay, Pekoe, etc. have because they have things about them that make them special and unique.

I have had Savannah several times and I NEVER liked her. I actually grew to dislike her and was glad that I was able to finally get rid of her and have her stop "haunting" my other towns. Just like Katt. I disliked Katt just as much. I also found Pekoe to be a paralyzing bore. Ugh.

I've never met Marshall before so I don't know first-hand. I'm always "meh" about a villager until I meet them myself. But yeah...when you grow to hate or dislike one it isn't likely you'll change your mind.

 

[LyraVale]

He is just a very VERY generic 'cute villager with nothing special'. He doesn't have any of the appeal that Hopper, Hans, Mira, Tucker, Ankha, Julain, Drago, Stitches, Savannah, Merengue, Clay, Pekoe, etc. have because they have things about them that make them special and unique.

I respect that. I do have to say though, what I find unique about him, is the expression on his face. It's what I fell in love with personally. He just reminds me of my cat. Walking around looking grumpy, but then the second you talk to him, he smiles and he's pleasant, which is seriously how my cat is. I'm not trying to influence your opinion of him, just saying if you do decide to take him on, he might not be so awful to have in town for a while.

 

[Straw hat]

I meant Lucky is IN the campsite, but Marshal has a plot set AT THE SAME TIME!. I was at 8 villagers, meaning I could take a plot and a camper.

Then get both! I'm aware you don't like Marshal, but take him for Lucky's sake and then, when he pings you, make a giveway or raffle him out. Someone will be really happy with this, ya know.

 

[Ami Mercury]

Then get both! I'm aware you don't like Marshal, but take him for Lucky's sake and then, when he pings you, make a giveway or raffle him out. Someone will be really happy with this, ya know.

I already did this. After some thought, I decided I want Bertha as Neo Mercury's new Normal. I already posted a thread in the trade forums, about trading him for her.