Honestly, I'm a little weirded out by the obsessive speculating over the sexual orientation of a chibi-looking character in a children's game with no mention of romance or sexuality whatsoever. I don't mean that like "being gay is inappropriate!!!11!! think of the children!!!" More like . . . I dunno, sometimes it seems like the cutesy Smug villagers who are not as traditionally masculine, like Raymond and Marshal, are claimed by overwhelmingly female players as being "my cutesy gay boi!! <3" despite the fact that canonically, none of the villagers have any sexual orientation whatsoever, and sometimes it comes across to me as just more of the typical fetishization of gay boys that women so often engage in. It's weird to superimpose an entire orientation on a cartoon cat and then treat him like a "collector's item" because of that orientation.
Really not trying to be a killjoy here, just thinking out loud. This is something I've heard my gay and bi friends talk about in real life, feeling almost like trading cards that other people are proud to have, the token non-straight person in a friend group or something similar. I know this is just a game but it feels like the fetishizing of LGBTQ+ orientations is pervasive enough to be pretty common even here.
Not accusing anyone in particular of anything; I can't now the gender identity or orientation of anyone here and I'm sure there's a lot of valid counterpoints to be made! I just wondered if anyone else had thought about it at all?
It's compounded by the fact that only the most "kawaii" of male villagers are typed this way, and only from one personality type, and thus the stereotype of "cute boy who likes clothes = gay" continues; I've never once seen anyone enthuse about how excited they were to get gay Hamphrey or gay Broccolo or gay Cesar in their town.
Anyone else have thoughts on this? I know I'm personally uncomfortable with introducing romance into AC in general (seeing fanart of, say, Rosie and Marshal on a date also makes me feel just kind of odd, like why do we have to shoehorn romance into everything all the time, especially in a series originally designed for children where almost everyone looks underage), so I'm sure I'm not looking at this specific trend through an unbiased lens.