What Do You Guys Think of Judy?

[Saga]

I don't really like how she looks, personally. Her colors are really pretty but her eyes look sort of evil or devious... I think it's the fact that they're so dark with no irises. But I can definitely see why she's popular - she fits a certain aesthetic extremely well.

That said, I recently did the same thing as you and adopted a villager I wasn't sure about. I don't really like the way goat villagers look, but I figured I'd give Sherb a chance since he came camping at a good time. Plus, like you, I figure I could always sell him if I ended up not liking him. Luckily, so far he's my favorite lazy villager I've had! He seems a bit calmer and like he has more dialogue than the other lazies I've had so far. So I might actually end up keeping him! Hopefully you'll end up lucking out and liking Judy, as well.

 

[sorachu]

My nephew has her on his town and she's really adorable. I think the sparkly eyes did it for me and her purple pastel scheme. I would get her but she's already at nephew's town and I could just visit her lol.

 

[fluttershy300]

As a fan of magical girl animes. I love her, she gives me those vibes. I have her on my island. Feels nice to have her.

 

[Envy]

TBH, she never stood out to me. She's obviously not ugly or anything, but she just doesn't do it for me.

 

[fluttershy300]

she has a very nice colour palette and she looks more like a peppy to me than a normal but she’s cute! she’s not a favourite of mine or anything but i wouldn’t be mad if she randomly moved in or something aha

She’s actually a snooty. :3

 

[Rosch]

I like her design. But she scares me. She's the type who would kill without hesitation.

 

[Bk1234]

I don't really like how she looks, personally. Her colors are really pretty but her eyes look sort of evil or devious... I think it's the fact that they're so dark with no irises. But I can definitely see why she's popular - she fits a certain aesthetic extremely well.

That said, I recently did the same thing as you and adopted a villager I wasn't sure about. I don't really like the way goat villagers look, but I figured I'd give Sherb a chance since he came camping at a good time. Plus, like you, I figure I could always sell him if I ended up not liking him. Luckily, so far he's my favorite lazy villager I've had! He seems a bit calmer and like he has more dialogue than the other lazies I've had so far. So I might actually end up keeping him! Hopefully you'll end up lucking out and liking Judy, as well.

Yeah, hopefully! Unfortunately, she falls under the heavy comparison to other Snooty villagers...

 

[Xara]

She’s actually a snooty. :3

lmao i got her and megan mixed up i went brainless while writing that smhh

 

[fluttershy300]

I like her design. But she scares me. She's the type who would kill without hesitation.

Lmao like Nui Harime from Kill La Kill. Cute but deadly. Chrissy gives those vibes too. It’s funny when we see something overly top cute we also think it has a sick twisted side to them. Makes the characters fun though!

 

[niko@kamogawa]

I like her design. But she scares me. She's the type who would kill without hesitation.

She and Pietro can make a fine team!

 

[marea]

She gives me evil mother in law vibes and i dont even know why!! Maybe it is something someone said or something. She is a no go for me.

 

[Darcy94x]

She’s so cute but also looks like she has an evil side I do want her though I’ve got every new villager except her! I wanted to try them all see if I got the hype!

 

[AmyK]

Not a fan, I have to admit. It's not that I have anything against her because everyone's got a different taste, so there are no "good or bad villagers" as such. Her design is just too much for me, especially the eyes. I don't know, she doesn't catch me. *shrugs* A friend of mine spent over 600 tickets to get her and I was so happy for them that I actually cried a little when they told me they finally found her, though. lol

 

[niko@kamogawa]

She gives me evil mother in law vibes and i dont even know why!! Maybe it is something someone said or something. She is a no go for me.

She’s so cute but also looks like she has an evil side I do want her though I’ve got every new villager except her! I wanted to try them all see if I got the hype!

I really like those type of characters though. However, we all know that Judy only has a snooty personality. I can only dream.

 

[0019293893]

She’s cute but honestly I’d pass her over for other snooty villagers first (Freya, Alli, Blanche, or Cleo).

 

[fuzzdebell]

I love how she looks both cute and also like she wouldn't hesitate to kill you in your sleep if you tick her off.

That is the perfect description of Judy. I found her on mystery island. Coincidentally I was looking for a snooty and she was the first snooty I found. At first I thought she is just a cute baby bear. But now I can see the deadly side of her. I'm mesmerized by her voice. She is growing on me now. You should see her at Bluebear's birthday party. She outshone everyone

 

[Shinjukuwu]

I'm a fan! She's so adorable and I love the pastel theme in general.

 

[Flunkifera]

I really like natural looking villagers, or if they look unnatural I like blue and red villagers, but I don't have too many pink and purple villagers that I like. Additionally I am a big fan of the cranky villagers and Judy fits none of these criteria. I am not fond of the ombre fur, I think her headshape look more like a hamster than anything else and I cannot stand the whole hype around her.

 

[Bk1234]

She’s cute but honestly I’d pass her over for other snooty villagers first (Freya, Alli, Blanche, or Cleo).

While I wouldn’t go for those Snooties (except maybe Blanche), Judy is definitely not my ideal Snooty.

Post automatically merged: Jul 1, 2020

That is the perfect description of Judy. I found her on mystery island. Coincidentally I was looking for a snooty and she was the first snooty I found. At first I thought she is just a cute baby bear. But now I can see the deadly side of her. I'm mesmerized by her voice. She is growing on me now. You should see her at Bluebear's birthday party. She outshone everyone

Part of the reason I took her is because I was looking for a Snooty (mainly Diana or Ankha) and I was running low on tickets.

 

[Halloqueen]

She's fine as far as I'm concerned, but not among my favorites or anything. I really love the coloration of her fur, but I'm not so fond of her "cutesy" sparkle eyes. My best friend really likes Judy and has her as a resident of her island after being extraordinarily lucky and finding her on a Nook Miles Island, and I'm totally content with seeing Judy out and about and talking to her while I'm visiting my friend's island. There are other villagers who I haven't had yet (or who I've had to get rid of because they didn't fit the themes of my towns) who I'm more interested in acquiring in future games though.