Biggest Animal Crosser exists because, even though the site is devoted to AC, there are still people who are more devoted to the game than others. Plus, excluding 2013, years 2009 - 2012 really didn't have that bigger AC community, especially in 2011 and 2012, barely anyone played AC, so the selection of members to chose from was smaller, and easier. I'm not too sure what the reasoning behind as to why Connor decided to make it an award, but I've always seen it as something worthwhile, which is why I've kept it in.