Villagers you liked at first but dislike now

[Reineke]

Basically any villager that picks fights. And for me right now, that villager is Renee . It really sucks, because, when I finally got her in my town, she didn't have her original shirt either (which is a huge part of her appeal). Its really weird though, because I have Fuchsia in my town too, and she never seems to get into any fights. Its led me to believe that within certain personality types there are subsets of it as well.

 

[toadsworthy]

Basically any villager that picks fights. And for me right now, that villager is Renee . It really sucks, because, when I finally got her in my town, she didn't have her original shirt either (which is a huge part of her appeal). Its really weird though, because I have Fuchsia in my town too, and she never seems to get into any fights. Its led me to believe that within certain personality types there are subsets of it as well.

what do you mean by picks fights with you?

 

[Reineke]

what do you mean by picks fights with you?

They don't pick fights with me, but rather the villagers will have rumors that get spread around town about who is bffs with whom, etc. One such rumor is which two villagers fight a lot, and sadly Renee is often mentioned in this rumor.

 

[ArtsyDreamer]

I liked Peanut when I had her in my first town for a little while, but then I got her in Wild World and she was a huge jerk... I've had quite a few peppies in that game, but none of them were mean like her 0.o She wore one of my favorite custom designs, only to call it hideous every time she talked about it, and when I tried to help her collect orange furniture, she totally freaked out on me when I didn't get the color quite right Even Baabara never did that when I messed up with her furniture, and snooties are known for being mean... 0.o So yeah, I wasn't too upset when Peanut moved out, and I maaay have nicknamed her "evil squirrel" XD

 

[Kitsey]

Dotty, Agnes, and Ribbot. Granted, I didn't spend much time with them. But, I really wanted all three and in the case of the last 2, used the villager reset trick for them. I think them all being mostly black and white or gray had something to do with it. I think Dotty would have been more enjoyable as a normal villager - I want my peppies to be colorful. I didn't like the design of their houses, either. Apparently I have something against the Lovely and Sleek furniture series. Dotty and Agnes had the same flooring too

 

[Lethalia]

I used to really like Whitney, especially back in the early AC days, but I realize now that she's pretty bland in comparison to other snooties. I don't dislike her at all, but I definitely don't like her as much as I did before. Overtime she just lost a lot of her appeal..I'd rather have Alli or Claudia.

 

[aleksandras]

probably fauna or beau, don't get me wrong, their design is wonderful. but for fauna, her design just started to feel really bland and boring, and so did her personality. unfortunately normal villagers don't have much dialogue variety. basically the same thing for beau, though i don't actually dislike him. he's just really overhyped, if i knew before buying him, i wouldn't have bought him. i suppose people only get him because he has high demand & they wanna show off, but in all honesty, he's boring.

edit -
i just realized this post goes along with the quote, "all that glitters is not gold" aha

 

[Buttonsy]

Peggy. She was in my campsite when I had had an empty 10th slot for a while and something was so ridiculously charming to me about how peppy and piggy both sounded like Peggy, who was a peppy piggy, so I instantly asked her to move in, but when she finally did, I felt no real affection towards her and then she started acting really mean to my other villagers, especially Dotty who was the first villager I really felt affection towards so she's very special to me...

 

[Awesomeness1230]

Fang was a dreamie at first but then when I got him I just went "nah" and got Chief instead.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Quite a few....
Stitches I always thought was creepy, never imagined that I would ever want him in my town. Whereas now he is one of my favourite villagers in my town and I really don't think I'll ever let him leave. It was only after seeing him multiple times in my friends town that changed my mind. Him being a lazy helps as I love them generally
Julian is another, for the same reasons as stitches, I just didn't like how his eyes were always closed. Decided to give him a try when I had a space come up and I just loved him. Not sure I would consider him a dreamie, he may leave at some point, but certainly one of my favourites.
Marshal I always thought was overrated. I couldn't understand what the fuss was over him. Never had plans to get him in my town, then I came on here and asked for dreams with him and I just loved that little bunch of pixels as soon as I walked in his house and saw him properly. Now he's one of my top dream villagers

 

[namiieco]

I liked Felicity at first but she got VERY repetitive after a day or so.

 

[satine]

Marshal. Everyone's freak out sort of did him in for me, sorry folks.

 

[lolita.x]

Henry the frog :/

 

[ashlif]

Stiches made me bored after a day or two in my WW town.I do like his design but he is overated and doesn't feel special as I thought I would.This might also go to Rosie as for her being overated. I might take Rosie out of my dreamy list at one point.

 

[Altarium]

I got Marina thinking having a pink octopus would spice up the normal personality. It didn't. She was so boring and bland.

 

[Plupap]

Lolly. At first, I found her completely adorable, and believed that she'd be one of my dreamies: but I really don't know; there was something about her grayscale design in conjunction with her normal personality that made me grow bored of her and even start to hate her a little bit. I've had Caroline in my town for a while now, and I still love her to pieces, so it's not just the personality...

Similar situation. I adopted Molly thinking she'd be adorable, but she literally did nothing in my town, and was completely boring. Then I adopted Caroline, and it was amazine. I love her so much.

 

[momokoleila]

I recall Kody the jock bear being like my ultimate animal crossing crush on Wild World when I was a lot younger. I really don't care for him now ;p

 

[rocklazy]

Whitney. I really did like her very much when she was in my old town and we were besties and all but then after a while she got a bit... bland and acted a bit different? Like I just kinda grew so distant I wanted to get rid of her (and besides I might have gotten tired of her since I had Ankha)

 

[treetops]

Marina. I used to like her a lot, but as time passed on, I just began to like her design less and less for how boring it really looks. Doesn't really help that I also dislike octopuses in general. But it's also funny to say because I disliked Zucker at first, but as time went on, he became my favourite octopus villager.

 

[Barnabus_i_am]

Muffy used to be my dreamie, but after a while I just stopped talking to her as much. She moved out suddenly, but I found that I didn't really mind.