Villagers you don’t understand the (un)popularity of

[Hydrangea028]

I like Elvis a lot, and the newest version of animal crossing definitely make his facial expression cuter. His house is very royal like (the lion king) and yes cranky villager’s conversation sometimes is quite funny. I really hope someday I can hug my villagers in this game.

 

[Manah]

I don't really understand why Apollo and Roald are so popular, the only thing I can see they have going for them is looking like natural animals. But it doesn't seem like "realistic" towns are all that popular and most people are going for cute/pastel. Literally every other eagle design looks more interesting than Apollo. (Also didn't expect Scoot to be that high on the tier list.)

Anyone who thinks Alice is bottom tier has not seen her adorable animations.

 

[Marta]

Carmen- She looks unique, fun, she’s peppy which is a fun personality, and she looks like such a nerdy type lol

Carmen is unpopular?? She's my bestie, definitely my favorite character so far! She is fun and nerdy and loves to talk about video games and space! She's amazing.

Chow - I never see people post about Chow, like he doesn't even exists. He appeared at my campsite and even though I wasn't sure, I invited him and I'm so glad I did. He is a cranky type but he is just the nicest, and most polite villager ever! When I see him around the island he gives the vibe that "he's living his best life" and instantly became friendly with all the other villagers. Maybe his look are a bit weird, but he's really won me over.

Post automatically merged: May 14, 2020

I don't really understand why Apollo and Roald are so popular

Roald is one of the starters on my island. I really like him though, he's really adorable in everything he does. Like, almost every night I find him asleep at the beach.. He's kind of silly and adorable. But on another island I had (on my boyfriend's switch) the starter was Dom and I still miss him. Roald is adorable but he lacks some personality that Dom definitely had, I have to admit.

 

[Jessi]

I hate that my boy cyd gets forgotten because of judy and raymond. He's the sweetest villager ever. He acts like a sweet grandpa always looking out for you. Everyone seems to hate on him or don't even know he exists, but he is probably one of my favorites out of the new villagers they added.

 

[Magus]

I hate that my boy cyd gets forgotten because of judy and raymond. He's the sweetest villager ever. He acts like a sweet grandpa always looking out for you. Everyone seems to hate on him or don't even know he exists, but he is probably one of my favorites out of the new villagers they added.

I totally agree, he's quite gentle for a Cranky.

 

[Blueskyy]

I saw Spike yesterday on an island. The only issue I had is that he looks more smug or jock than cranky. But he was cool. But yeah horses like Papi and Annalise need more love. Also like Cheri a lot and dislike Lucky a lot.

 

[Sencha]

When I first saw the tier list, I was honestly really surprised at most of them. Felicity was really low, but she’s adorable, and Lolly is really high, but they are pretty similar so why so different in tier?A lot of ”basic” villagers are high, but some are low, and I can’t figure out what makes some of them popular but not others.

I agree on Lucky, I find him creepy. I also don’t like the food themed villagers, I don’t get them. And Gladys and Nan are criminally underrated, they are the sweetest

 

[Lazaros]

very popular-unpopular opinion to have, but:
i don't get the appeal about raymond. he's a cat villager - and despite being cat crazy irl i like almost none of them - and also his glasses look ... yeah, not good. the most popular opinion i see is his heterochromia, because it's unique to him, but it's literally just eyes. he looks like the white hipster guys that people on 2012 tumblr were swooning over and calling all kinds of things. absolutely not my thing and i wouldn't bet an eyelash if satan would ask me to sell raymond to him for one corn chip.

same with marshal. the change in some color palettes for new horizons turned him from a pleasant to look at white marshmallow squirrel into a blob of mayonnaise and i can't unsee it. i just don't see what's so good about him either, though. he did fit my town theme in NL, so he can stay, no questions asked, but seriously? why love a mayonnaise creacher?

 

[BipolarBear]

Leonardo. The fact that I even have to explain why he should be more popular makes me question my sanity. He's a really adorable cheetah what's not to love, it's Crazytown!

 

[coderp]

Popular villagers I'm not fond of:

• Diana
• Merengue
• Marshall
• Beau
• Whitney
• Raymond

Unpopular villagers I AM fond of:

• GOOSE!!!!! I love this dude.
• Kody
• Bruce
• Ken
• Lopez
• Amelia
• Avery
• Ketchup

There's more, but this is the gist of it.

 

[oofyscoop]

barold moved in to my town... i hope if i get whitney or skye i can hide behind them and they attack barold to death....

Post automatically merged: May 14, 2020

Popular villagers I'm not fond of:

• Diana
• Merengue
• Marshall
• Beau
• Whitney
• Raymond

Unpopular villagers I AM fond of:

• GOOSE!!!!! I love this dude.
• Kody
• Bruce
• Ken
• Lopez
• Amelia
• Avery
• Ketchup

There's more, but this is the gist of it.

wait how is avery unpopular?! i have him and he is my favorite villager i have!

 

[visibleghost]

honestly, all frogs except for lily (because she's popular) and jambette because i understand that she isn't pretty but i still like her because she's a frog. ok also the ugly grey frog, idk his name but i'm not a huge fan. but the rest of them!!!

but, like, say puddles or gigi. both totally adorable frogs but not popular at all. or frobert! he's so beautiful. jeremiah is also very cute but i don't think people dislike him that much, i might be wrong though heh.

 

[Blueskyy]

I feel like the big bears in general are not very popular, which is a shame because they are pretty great.

But he's a cute bear cub! He's not even one of the big ones! I am no saint. I also am partial to small animals. I do prefer cubs over regular bears, although Tutu and Megan are cute big bears. But this is super cute little Murphy!

Post automatically merged: May 13, 2020

sorry the pic sucked lmao. Site wouldn't accept the larger and better quality one I had.

Edit: Wow I accidentally replied twice it this got messy haha
[/QUOTE]
I ALMOST took Murphy from an island because he is in My NL but let him go. He is awesome!

 

[AdehhRR]

Leonardo. The fact that I even have to explain why he should be more popular makes me question my sanity. He's a really adorable cheetah what's not to love, it's Crazytown!

Yes! Leonardo and Rodeo both surprised me with their position on the tier list !

 

[seularin]

don't know if she's unpopular... but MELBA !! ugh shes my new dreamie

 

[ForeverALoan]

Im sorry but Rodeo high key scares me

 

[Hats002]

I don't know why Snake is so unpopular. One of my favorite jocks man :C

same! I love snake so much, he's so funny in new leaf and makes me smile all the time. when i first saw him i didn't like him that much but he's become one of my faves!!

 

[Mo Notony]

I love me some Jambette and Patty...they're both sweethearts and I'm NEVER letting them leave my island!!

 

[Lokidoki]

Honestly my fav species are the kangaroos, Walt and Mathilda def have the cool looking houses, but they really didn't make any of the kanga homes wanted in my book, in new leaf they had the awesome play rooms, baby cradles, a simple toybox - is that where they sleep or in the pouch ow those kicks

I don't like freya or whitney, the only popular villager that deserves the super s tier has to be Stitches!

 

[Pate and Ketchup]

Popular villagers I don't really like :
Sherb : he looks a little bit stupid for me, sorry. I love his color, but he's not exceptionnal
Raymond : I have something against him. Seriously. He has originality, of course, but... I don't like his expression, maybe ?
Audie : I kinda hate her peppy face. For me she looks unbearable
Goldie : it's just a dog
Cherry : I'm sorry, I really dislike her look

Less popular villagers I really like :
Canberra : I've seen a sad comic about her, so my mind is affected, yes
Sprocket : I love his robot face !
Cousteau : I can't explain, I really really love his facial expression
Kidd : Same as before, I have no argument haha
Raddle : I find him really original and I like the color of his skin !
Sterling : I love middle age villagers, don't ask me why
Beardo : love his color, love his hair, he's chic
Lionel : he's chic too
Broccolo : I want him on my island. I really want him. I need him. He's the cutest villager I've ever seen !
Chester : I love his little cute face, come please

Quite weird, but still my choice !