Villagers you don’t understand the (un)popularity of

[Dude_Skillz]

Half of Raymond’s fan base is people looking for him to sell him.

Post automatically merged: May 13, 2020

I don’t understand Merry’s popularity. Every time I see her face I puke

Post automatically merged: May 13, 2020

Her eyes...No.

 

[angelprincesskiki]

I may be biased since she’s my favorite, but I’m surprised Peanut isn’t more popular. I mean, she’s a cute little pink squirrel, what’s not to love?

Agree! I remember seeing her on the wild world cover and constantly hoping she would move into my town. I've wanted her ever since and only just got her in NH & she is my fave.

 

[Pixiebelle]

pls nobody hate me for this, we all have our favs and it's just my opinion !!

popular:
Marshal. He's cute, yeah. Apart from that idk I just don't get the hype. Would probably have him on my island as a placeholder but otherwise... ehh.
Judy. Again, cute. But like, almost too cute is that even a thing? I usually love that aesthetic but for some reason her eyes bother me, they don't seem to 'fit'.

unpopular:
Tia. Margie. Opal. All of the elephants...
Carrie. Kangaroos don't seem that popular but I have a soft spot for Carrie, she just seems really sweet lol
Kid Cat. Jocks aren't usually my cup of tea but this guy is awesome.

 

[Santana]

Popular:
Raymond: Don’t get me wrong, I love raymond, its just insane the lengths people are going for him

Coco: Whew chile i am going to get so much hate for this. I just think she’s scary

Diana: She is cute ig, but her design doesn’t stick out that much to me

Zucker: Never been a fan of his color palette, and the fact that he references takoyaki doesn’t do much for me

Marshal: Is cute, not that special to me tho

alot of people in this thread feel the same way I felt about Judy when she first moved in, but after a week I’m so attached to judy it’s crazy

Unpopular:

Skye, Jaques, Dobie, Tia, Kyle, Shep, Vivian, Sylvana, Maggie and Pierce

 

[Figment]

Before I joined TBT, I had no clue Marshal was as popular as he is. Though it makes more sense to me now. At any rate, I think he is cute.

I would have thought Midge would be much more popular than she is. Actually, I would have thought bird villagers in general would be more desired than they are, but most seem to be much lower tiered than I would have thought.

 

[Santana]

Before I joined TBT, I had no clue Marshal was as popular as he is. Though it makes more sense to me now. At any rate, I think he is cute.

I would have thought Midge would be much more popular than she is. Actually, I would have thought bird villagers in general would be more desired than they are, but most seem to be much lower tiered than I would have thought.

I totally forgot about Midge. Midge is too cute to be in E tier

 

[ChrissyAndFrancineLover]

I'll never understand why Spike isn't liked more. He's one of the coolest looking characters for me.

I know right! I love Spike! I wish I had him on my island!

 

[Believe]

Prince is REALLY cute I don't understand how he's so low. in fact, I don't understand how the frogs are so disliked?

 

[Eevees]

Gayle, shes a sweet pink gator with hearts. Whats not to love?

 

[Spooky.]

I don't get the popularity of Raymond, Julian, Zucker (or any octopus)

I don't get the unpopularity of Filbert, Antonio, Deidre

 

[Miele]

Popular:
Raymond - maybe it’s the fact that I’m not a huge of cat villagers (with Olivia being the exception), but I just don’t find the appeal. His eyes are cool, but other than that, nothing is appealing. Tbh, he’s just another cat/smug villager. Nothing special about him.

Judy - LOVE the aesthetic around her but omg, HATE her eyes. They’re so creepy to me and I can’t her past them. Plus, the snooty personality doesn’t fit her imo

Marshal - I liked him a lot in NL, but I don’t see the appeal to him anymore. I love the squirrel villagers, but he’s just another pretty boy.
•••
Unpopular:
Olivia - I don’t get how she isn’t more popular. She’s honestly one of my favourite villagers and I just love her so much.

Felicity - she’s much prettier, imo, than Ankha or Lolly. And her peppy personality is adorable.

Hamphrey - he’s a cranky hamster. With shortness comes cranky (I relate to this since I’m 5’2 and I, too, don’t want to be bothered)

 

[Etown20]

My starters were Flo and Cobb - I think they're both great and am surprised they are rarely mentioned, Flo especially.

 

[Dude_Skillz]

This may be biased(hence my profile pic) but Walker is totally underrated. you know how there are like 10 lazy dogs? Walker is #1(even better than Lucky)

 

[Spooky.]

I've never understood what the appeal in Marshal is. He really doesn't look that interesting. It also surprises me how popular Judy is. When I first saw her I didn't think people would care for her much.
I don't understand why jocks are generally so unpopular, I think they're so funny.
And Hamphrey! I think Hamphrey is so lovable!

My guess in jocks being generally unpopular is because the jock type isn't exactly what the typical fanbase of animal crossing is interested in. Most players see it as a cutesy, flower, gardening, decorating, cute stuff and jock types just...aren't that.

 

[JKDOS]

I don't understand how Mitzi is is not more popular.

 

[Rosewater]

There's too many unpopular villagers I don't understand why they don't get more love. A lot of the dog villagers get overlooked like Daisy, Biskit, Maddie, and Butch but they're so cute. Some of the squirrels are underrated too like Sylvana, Static, and Pecan. I also don't get why Sterling and Snake are unpopular when their design is awesome but I suppose it's because they're jocks and a lot of people here don't like the jocks.

Popular villagers, besides the obvious, I'll say Lolly. Her eyes are creepy and she looks like she's lacking something. And Marina. I had Marina in Wild World and she was a total snoozefest.

 

[Dude_Skillz]

There's too many unpopular villagers I don't understand why they don't get more love. A lot of the dog villagers get overlooked like Daisy, Biskit, Maddie, and Butch but they're so cute. Some of the squirrels are underrated too like Sylvana, Static, and Pecan. I also don't get why Sterling and Snake are unpopular when their design is awesome but I suppose it's because they're jocks and a lot of people here don't like the jocks.

Popular villagers, besides the obvious, I'll say Lolly. Her eyes are creepy and she looks like she's lacking something. And Marina. I had Marina in Wild World and she was a total snoozefest.

Exactly. the dogs are the most underrated species ever.

 

[trashpedia]

Chevre and Carmen are super underrated imo. I’m surprised Chevre is even low to begin with because she has a minimal yet cute design that I think would fit the the all-white theme people are going with their islands. As for Carmen, she has and interesting mint color palette!

 

[Shinjukuwu]

Opal is a pretty green color with lovely eyes. Elephants in general have some of my favorite designs.
Tasha looks like a skunk! That is so unique. She would fit in well with islands going for a forestry, country, or modern look.
Keaton is smug so he has some tough competition but he has such a great design. He has those smirking smug eyes and a nice coloring.

Yessss to Opal! She is gorgeous, and the only villager I spent £10 on an Amiibo card for. I've not added her to my island yet but will at some point

 

[Babypink]

Exactly. the dogs are the most underrated species ever.

Yeah I really don’t understand why...they are almost all adorable!

There's too many unpopular villagers I don't understand why they don't get more love. A lot of the dog villagers get overlooked like Daisy, Biskit, Maddie, and Butch but they're so cute. Some of the squirrels are underrated too like Sylvana, Static, and Pecan. I also don't get why Sterling and Snake are unpopular when their design is awesome but I suppose it's because they're jocks and a lot of people here don't like the jocks.

Popular villagers, besides the obvious, I'll say Lolly. Her eyes are creepy and she looks like she's lacking something. And Marina. I had Marina in Wild World and she was a total snoozefest.

I always wondered why Sylvana or Poppy are underrated. They are adorable! Also, the dogs are so cute, I wish I had Bea or Maddie