villagers that you will never ever kick out?

ekcomyth

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2020
Posts
233
Bells
189
what are some villagers that you will never kick out? mine are

Clay (i never knew he would become my ultimate dreamier until i had him)
Dom (i knew i wanted this fluffy delusional sheep the first time i saw him but every passing day my fondness for him just grew)
Raymond (got him through the island and because he's too popular and very expensive to get imma keep him forever. also because i like him very much)
Reneigh (Her overall design just fits my aesthetic so much)
 
Last edited:
for me, i only have one so far; i haven't had too many move-outs yet, so i'm still in the beginning stages of getting my dreamies. i'm also trying to get as many portraits as i can, however, so it might take me a bit to settle on some set villagers.

right now, however, lobo is my permanent wolf. he isn't going anywhere. his house fits my island extremely well, too, so that's a huge added bonus. he was my first grumpy, and because of that, it just feels like he's the resident old man who likes to bark at everyone when they get too close to his lawn 😅 he has a very special spot in my heart, and my island.
 
Never will I ever kick out Whitney 😍 She has been with me on every animal crossing game and it wouldn’t be the same without her.

Julian isn’t going anywhere, I adore his house and he always seems to end up in my town. Bianca is one of my favs so she has to stay. Audie is fabulous. Had her since the beginning of New Horisons. Sadly that is the problem and she is still in her starter house.

Reneigh I’m not sure of. She has been in town for a long time and I just don’t get her 😂
 
None yet ... There are nearly 400 villagers in the game, hundreds of which I'm sure I have never met before in previous games, so I want to meet them all before I even consider keeping any of them permanently ...

I do have some personal favourites, though, Gruff being tops at the moment. Also Rasher, Stinky, Lily, Tabby, Pietro, Al, O'Hare ...

Kyle is on my island at the moment and I think he's becoming another favourite ... Once I can subjectively make my mind up, I'll think about what 10 villagers I might want to keep around ...
 
Colton is the one that I can't imagine kicking out. He's the prince of the land. There are others that are almost at that level: Raymond, Genji, Poppy, Skye, Dom. Maybe Sherb. I don't like his house exterior since it's blue color doesn't match the rest of the island design but he's so cute, I can't bear to get rid of him.

There are some that I have Amiibo cards for and I kicked them but then missed them and invited them back weeks or months later--Kidd and Fauna and Knox.
 
I think I would burst into flames if I let go of Dom, Merengue, or Maple. I'd probably be super upset about the rest but those would hurt the worst. I always tense up if any of them ask to leave because I don't want to accidentally say go lol!!
 
Tucker, Bianca, Tad and Goldie for me, from least likely to most likely if I was somehow to find someone I like more than anyone on that list if that makes sense.
 
I think at this point, I wouldn't kick any of my villagers out unless I was transferring them to a second island or knowing they would go to a good home. I like them all, plus, some weren't easy to get.

Some villagers that are never EVER leaving are Pierce and Dom. Dom is such a cutie and Peirce has really grown on me. A villager I would transfer to a second island if I had one is Avery. Avery doesn't really have a yard in my current island. I wanted to give him a secluded forest area surrounded by rocks, but I had changed my theme so he now lives in my fishing village.
 
I won’t kick out Lolly. She’s adorable and she reminds me of both cats I’ve had irl because they’ve been grey. I doubt I’d kick out Cole either just because he’s so cute and he was my boyfriend’s first favorite villager. He still talks about him moving out of his NL town lol.
 
I try never to say never, but I do have a super short list of islanders I don't intend to move out in the forseeable future.

Raymond is my favourite cat right now. He did cost me 3 days of my life because that was how long it took to get him using the camp site method. That's not the reason though. I'm just super fond of Raymond. I like how he looks, I'm tickled by how he acts. His smiles melt my heart.

Claude is the only remaining one of my first 5 villagers. He still has his starter home. But that's okay. If Claude's happy with it, I'm happy with it. I cannot explain why he's so special to me. He just is. If I don't see him around, I panic, and I cannot calm down until I find him and talk to him. If we could hug our animals, he's the first one I'd hug.

Rolf is my favourite cranky. I've known him since Wild World and New Leaf. I didn't look for him in New Horizons but he turned up on one of the mystery islands early on in my game. I had to invite him. And then I just fell in love with him all over again.

Fuchsia is my MVP. My favourite uchi. She has a lot of backstory as she often mentions her parents, her grandparents, and the people on the island where she lived before moving to mine. I love how she does not mince her words. She's honest and independent and worldly wise.
 
I wouldn't kick out:
Antonio - my last OG villager, and he's hilarious. I love when he does his pumps.
Raymond - because it's Raymond and I love him.
Marshal - who I think is inching towards my favorite.
Fauna - I love her and I got her from a friend, and she was my first villager obtained through trade.
Lopez - I love Lopez. I have his picture, but I still can't picture kicking him off the island.
Reneigh - I haven't bonded with her yet, but she's still relatively new and she doesn't have an amiibo, so she'll stay.
Audie - my nickname is Fox, so it seems only appropriate for me to keep her. Plus, she doesn't have an amiibo. Even though as far as peppy villagers are concerned, I like Chrissy and Bubbles better so far.
 
Last edited:
Dom - he's such a cutie, I remember only getting him to sell him later but he's grown on me so much he's become one of my absolute favorites now 💗
Then also Merengue and Kiki since I planned to have them on my island beforehand and luckily found them with island hopping.

And technically I wouldn't ever kick my no 1 boy Lucky out if I didn't have his amiibo card but I do so he has been traveling quite a lot lol.
 
Tank- he’s one of my starters and although I wish he had his real house, he’s special because we started together
Deirdre- shes one of the only sisterly villagers I like
I may also keep Vivian, Fauna, Papi, and Ellie
 
Tank- he’s one of my starters and although I wish he had his real house, he’s special because we started together
Deirdre- shes one of the only sisterly villagers I like
I may also keep Vivian, Fauna, Papi, and Ellie
I have a hard time with the sisterly villagers too. I couldn't stand charlise or pashmina.
 
Out of my current line-up, the only villager I'm keeping around indefinitely is Judy, simply because I have no guaranteed way of finding her again relatively effortlessly. I found and adopted both Phoebe and Raymond with the intention that I would be cycling them to my partner, both of whom will be part of his permanent villager line-up. Otherwise, I am much more inclined to keep things fresh for myself on my island by seeing new and different faces. For example, as much as I love Agnes, once I got her framed photo a second time, I thought to myself, "Will I really want to receive a third one?", so I took her off my list of long-term/permanent villagers.
 
I’m currently trying to get all the new villagers in this iteration of animal crossing in my village. I currently have 4 of said villagers. Judy, Raymond, Megan and Audie. I’m only missing Renieigh, sherb, Dom and Cyd. I’d say those are my dreamies thus far. I loved stitches in new leaf, he was my favorite, so he’s on my island by amibo card and is staying.
 
For me I think the only villager I am 100% on right now is Peewee (he is my favourite villager since I was a kid). In the maybe permanent category: Cookie, Tipper and Erik. I don't really want to completely fill up my island with permanent residents though because I think having them move and getting to try out new people is part of the fun of the game.
 
Back
Top