Has anyone gotten anything unorderable (even if it was something you gave them at one point and that they ended up replacing with something else in their house) from a villager or from their closet? I just realized recently that Kiki replaced the Gracie Shelf in her house with some item I must've given me and I've been wondering if (since my Re-Tail is full; I'm hesitant to take anything off of Re-Tail since I've given villagers some furniture I want them to keep) I could ever come across it again. I still haven't seen Gaston's Sloppy Bed or Cardboard Table that he had originally. :/
The Gracie furniture can't go up for sale at retail. Try opening her closet when you visit. Maybe you'll get lucky.
I have a side town where I remove all the items from retail and wait for them to put sloppy/ cardboard items. Received 2 full sets of each and it still keeps showing up. I don't care about their house since it's just a place to grow perfect fruit and store items.
Wow nice. I got a throne from Punchy in the mail; so far, I haven't found anything that great in their closets. I forgot who it was, but someone gave me a sprinkler.