Pretty soon I'm getting a second copy of the game. I wanted to make a themed town, and I think I'll make a forest themed town. I have a few villagers in mind, but I'm not sure who I definitely want. I also want to try to have one of every personality and a few different species. Feel free to give feedback or suggest other villagers.
Here are the villagers I have in mind:
-Molly (normal)
-Drake (lazy)
-Bill (jock)
-Fauna (normal)
-Erik (lazy)
-Bam (jock)
-Poppy (normal)
-Chief (cranky)
-Blaire (snooty)
-Bunnie (peppy)
-Sparro (jock)
-Henry (smug)
-Deirdre (uchi)
-Fuchsia (uchi)
Bill - Jock
Henry - Smug
Grizzly - Cranky
Erik - Lazy
Poppy - Normal
Deirdre - Uchi
Bonbon - Peppy
Pecan - Snooty
Peck or Sparro - Jock
Molly or Maple - Normal
I thought Grizzly would add more diversity to your list, and make for a good cranky, and that Bonbon looked more natural than Bunnie. I also agree with the person who suggested Maple. It's your game though, choose the villagers you like the best.
Go for a natural look. Animals like Skye, Jambette, and Fuschia won't fit the bill since wolfs aren't blue, frogs don't wear lipsticks, and deer aren't pink.