Villager Dilemma

[MindlessPatch]

So recently I've been thinking about my dream villagers and I haven't got a uchi or jock character. I recently swapped a normal out for a snooty (Purrl) and she's happily living in my town right now. I'm not to stressed about an uchi character but I would like a jock.

Basically...
I'd like Kid Cat as my jock character but I don't know who he would replace. I'd like your help in deciding that. All input is appreciated!

My current dreamies are:
1 snooty (Purrl)
1 cranky (Chief)
1 peppy (Rosie)
2 smug (Zell & Marshal)
2 normal (Lolly & Mitzi)
3 lazy (Zucker, Beau & Punchy)

I'm considering swapping him for Mitzi, Lolly, Zucker or Beau.

I'm kind of leaning towards Zucker because I have 3 lazies and he's the only octopus so maybe he'll get a bit lonely...

Added a few reasons. (+ = Positives of that villager. – = Negatives of that villager. ~ = Neutral)

Spoiler: Mitzi

+ She's a cat (want mostly cats in my town)
+ She was my first favourite in Wild World
+ Already have her in town
– Second normal
– Think I'd honestly prefer Lolly over her (although Mitzi has a special place in my heart for being my first favourite so I don't know whether I want to let her go...)

Spoiler: Lolly

+ She's a flipping adorable cat (once again mostly cats)
– Second normal

Spoiler: Beau

~ Second deer
– Third lazy

Spoiler: Zucker

+ Goes with my sweets house (possible sweet/fairy tail town, undecided on this though)
~ Only octopus
– Third lazy

Do you think it would be annoying having 3 lazy villagers in my town?

 

[CR33P]

do what you want. it's your town.

 

[MindlessPatch]

That's what I can't decide on though haha.

 

[brooklyn9]

i'm thinking mitzi. two normal cats seems like too much.
i think lolly is cuter

 

[Bearica]

I'm gonna say Mitzi. I might be biased because I have Lolly in my town, but imo, she's a lot cuter than Mitzi and 2 normal cats seems like overkill.

 

[sn0wxyuki]

Since your town gonna have a lot of cats I would suggest let Zucker go =D but then this is your town so go for which your heart telling you right now =D we cannot help you make your final decision xD

 

[pinkx2]

Beau, he's not that cute or unique!

 

[Libra]

Either Zucker or Beau since you have three lazies. ^_^

 

[MindlessPatch]

Thanks everyone for your input so far c:

I'll end up making the final decision by myself but I'd like some help just to push me towards picking between two. Picking between four myself is too much for me haha c;

 

[MindlessPatch]

Morning bump. C:

 

[Gizmodo]

Mitzi>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Lolly
and Mitzi is far underrated
Or Zucker hes cool

 

[Hound00med]

Definitely Zucker or Lolly.

Mitzi is far too cute, and Beau is better than those other two, plus he'd pair well with Zell..

Zucker is just insanely ugly and Lolly isn't much better.. Mitzi ftw

 

[MindlessPatch]

Thanks everyone for the votes c: Input is still welcome ^^