Unpopular opinions?

[ams]

I was under the impression plot resetting was for getting villager houses in desired locations? But if that's not true, I agree. It really only makes sense to plot reset for villagers during your uchi/smug move in days of a new town, since that cuts down the possibilities.

(I totally got Phoebe through successful plot resetting during the uchi move-in phase of Baker though ahahah)

Plot resetting does just refer to the location after a campsite/other town move-in is established. I think he was talking about villager reseting.

I used villager/campsite resetting to get 9/10 of my villagers and it took me like 2 evenings last weekend. Keep in mind that it will always fill in the missing personality (not just in the beginning with smug/uchi) so you can do this for 8/10, then campsite reset the first day it's built for the 9th. I'm still shocked more people who don't plot reset don't use this method.

 

[The221Believer]

Plot resetting does just refer to the location after a campsite/other town move-in is established. I think he was talking about villager reseting.

I used villager/campsite resetting to get 9/10 of my villagers and it took me like 2 evenings last weekend. Keep in mind that it will always fill in the missing personality (not just in the beginning with smug/uchi) so you can do this for 8/10, then campsite reset the first day it's built for the 9th. I'm still shocked more people who don't plot reset don't use this method.

Is it that reliable? I had two snooties already and no peppies or normals when Whitney showed up; I thought it just tended towards favouring missing personalities. Maybe my game's just weird. Wouldn't surprise me.

I wish the campsite were predictable, though, I love seeing new villagers in there and it's never built. >>

 

[Link of Hyrule]

I love Pete always telling me my mailbox is full.

 

[ams]

Is it that reliable? I had two snooties already and no peppies or normals when Whitney showed up; I thought it just tended towards favouring missing personalities. Maybe my game's just weird. Wouldn't surprise me.

I wish the campsite were predictable, though, I love seeing new villagers in there and it's never built. >>

It is there's just a weird pattern.

Spoiler: this might get boring

So in my town Filbert was a starter and my only Lazy. The way it works is that I need to void (or give away) him, then void another villager. The first to move in after he leaves will not be lazy, but the second to move in after Filbert leaves is guaranteed to be lazy. I've done this many times and it is 100% reliable. You just have to get a bit of a pattern for move-outs so you don't get more than 1 undesired move-in (I ended up with just 1). So for example I void Filbert, get a random (undesired) move-in, then void Claudia, then I can reset for lazy, void another villager, reset for snooty etc.

 

[Rasha]

- Ankha is very ugly
- Myrengue (still can't pronounce her name) is ugly
- Zucker should be in tier 3, Octavian is way cooler looking than him
- what is Kid Cat doing there? he's cute but is more on the meh side
- Lucky is extremely meh
- marshal is popular for a reason, he belongs at the top
- Julian should be higher

 

[chainosaur]

Black hybrids are ugly, Jocks are great, and I think the vast majority of cutesy fairy-tale themed towns are same-y. Very boring.

 

[axo]

Merengue has literally 0 personality.
Bob is just a more popular version of Moe who is actually a better lazy cat overall. I'd take punchy or moe over bob anyday.

 

[Byngo]

I was under the impression plot resetting was for getting villager houses in desired locations? But if that's not true, I agree. It really only makes sense to plot reset for villagers during your uchi/smug move in days of a new town, since that cuts down the possibilities.

(I totally got Phoebe through successful plot resetting during the uchi move-in phase of Baker though ahahah)

My mistake, I meant campsite resetting. lel

 

[Raffy]

I don't understand how one has less personality if they are both the same personality.

can someone actually explain this to me.

 

[axo]

can someone actually explain this to me.

Villagers within certain categories (lazy, jock, etc) can talk about different things. For instance, Merengue, a normal villager, talks a lot about baking, while other normal villagers might talk about... Books or travel or something like that. I personally dont like the way she always talks about baking, it's like she can't talk about anything else. I much prefer Flurry, who talks about books, and clothes, and a wide variety of other things.

 

[The221Believer]

It is there's just a weird pattern.

Spoiler: this might get boring

So in my town Filbert was a starter and my only Lazy. The way it works is that I need to void (or give away) him, then void another villager. The first to move in after he leaves will not be lazy, but the second to move in after Filbert leaves is guaranteed to be lazy. I've done this many times and it is 100% reliable. You just have to get a bit of a pattern for move-outs so you don't get more than 1 undesired move-in (I ended up with just 1). So for example I void Filbert, get a random (undesired) move-in, then void Claudia, then I can reset for lazy, void another villager, reset for snooty etc.

Not boring at all, but gosh, that's weird but interesting information. Maybe I can use that when I get rid of Fang and replace him with Roscoe... Thanks for teaching me something new!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Black hybrids are ugly, Jocks are great, and I think the vast majority of cutesy fairy-tail themed towns are same-y. Very boring.

Also, agreed on the last: I'm soooo over the cutesy aesthetic in general. I use fairy-tale for Moriarty's house in my town because it's thematically appropriate for the episode his house embodies (as he says, "every fairytale needs a good old fashioned villain"). Other than things like that where it's there for a reason, it's so BORING.

 

[ams]

Not boring at all, but gosh, that's weird but interesting information. Maybe I can use that when I get rid of Fang and replace him with Roscoe... Thanks for teaching me something new!

Just wanted to be clear that only applies to random move-ins, not campsite villagers (they're completely random). But yeah if you have ten, drop Fang, then drop someone else the new (random) 9th villager will be cranky as long as you don't have any other crankies.

Anyways I feel like I've been spamming this thread like crazy.

My unpopular opinion is that Marshal kind of reminds me of moody, girl-crazy boys in middle school and it creeps me out.

 

[Bosca]

Villagers within certain categories (lazy, jock, etc) can talk about different things. For instance, Merengue, a normal villager, talks a lot about baking, while other normal villagers might talk about... Books or travel or something like that. I personally dont like the way she always talks about baking, it's like she can't talk about anything else. I much prefer Flurry, who talks about books, and clothes, and a wide variety of other things.

I thought I was imagining things when my same type villagers seem so different, like Naomi was really boring, but Timbra was hilarious and I couldn't work out why..so maybe Timbra really is more sassy.

On topic, Canberra is adorable to me and I really don't care for forest towns..tho if you make it 50% town and 50% forest that's cool.

 

[axo]

I thought I was imagining things when my same type villagers seem so different, like Naomi was really boring, but Timbra was hilarious and I couldn't work out why..so maybe Timbra really is more sassy.

On topic, Canberra is adorable to me and I really don't care for forest towns..tho if you make it 50% town and 50% forest that's cool.

Canberra is so cute, she would be my dreamie but my town is food themed.

 

[erikaeliseh]

i dont love gold roses, i dont like orange hybrids

 

[disneydorky]

-I don't like orange hybrids, that's been said often, but it's true.
- I don't like cat or wolf villagers they bother me, I think it may be the ears.
-I'm probably getting rid of most of my tier 1 villagers except for a couple of my favorites because I'm sick of seeing the same villagers in every dream town, including mine.
- I love Gracie and wish she were easier to get, or there from the beginning like in City Folk.

 

[FelicityShadow]

- The villager tier system is overrated. I feel like we're selling our villagers like slaves.
- I dislike paths, plot resetting, and town layout resetting. I like a random placement and "natural town."
- I really don't care about the dream suite and it'll probably be the second to last badge I will bother getting (the last being streetpass)
- I don't care about making designs at Able sisters
- I love tier five and four villagers more than tier one villagers. If anyone gives them away, I will gladly take them.

I'll think of more tomorrow. lol

 

[TheGreatBrain]

I think most of the uchi villagers are cute. So many people say they're ugly.

Sylvia and Marcie are adorable. I'm surprised that the kangaroos aren't more popular. I love that they have a baby joey in their pocket.

 

[Shimmer]

I don't like the look of most of the paths. I'm VERY picky with them which is why I just want to do a natural path for my town. The fake water and grass look terrible. In photos they can look okay but in the actual game, it's awkward when everything is moving and the water isn't flowing. I appreciate the artists' hard work on making them but they just look weird to me. I have NEVER seen an instance yet where it looks good.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm going to add the fact that I also don't really like the look of the fairy tale Public Works Projects. Everyone seems to love them and I just don't get it. xD

 

[ThatRandomMayor]

Mira is overrated
I don't think Muffy is overrated
I don't think the uchis are rude