Two Roscoes too many?

[silver_shroud]

I'm having (yet another) villager dilemma and could use some outside perspective. I've had Roscoe in my 'rock and roll' themed town for awhile and absolutely LOVE the guy. But recently I also created an all-horse town, which Roscoe is a part of as well. Do you think having the same villager in two towns is overkill? A part of me was considering bringing Bruce into Rock City since I've really been wanting him and he would also fit the theme very nicely... but I feel like Roscoe has become an integral part of Rock City (plus his color scheme matches my custom tiles perfectly). What do you guys think?

 

[ellabella12345]

Nah I don't think that having them in 2 of your towns is too much. I just think that maybe you should try mix it up. Like there is no point in having the same villager, why not have someone different? Pick someone unique and still amazing to you! (Just my opinion) but if you really love Roscoe then meh, why not have 2 of him!

 

[silver_shroud]

Nah I don't think that having them in 2 of your towns is too much. I just think that maybe you should try mix it up. Like there is no point in having the same villager, why not have someone different? Pick someone unique and still amazing to you! (Just my opinion) but if you really love Roscoe then meh, why not have 2 of him!

I know what you mean about mixing things up. Getting the chance to interact wit lots of different villager has definitely been one of the biggest benefits of having multiple towns for me. And I *have* become rather smitten with Bruce as of late.. ugh, that 10 villager max thing is killing me once again!

 

[ellabella12345]

I know what you mean about mixing things up. Getting the chance to interact wit lots of different villager has definitely been one of the biggest benefits of having multiple towns for me. And I *have* become rather smitten with Bruce as of late.. ugh, that 10 villager max thing is killing me once again!

Sounds like you need more towns! But I would love to cycle through all villagers in another town if I could!

 

[littlebabymonster]

No way. I have him, too. Roscoe is a great villager and if you enjoy having him in both towns, that's all that matters.

 

[roseflower]

You can never have too much Roscoes c; If you like him for your two towns it`s okay. And you can always decide to move one of them out, if you like to see new faces.

 

[JJarmon]

Hey, if you like a character, there's no harm in having him twice! On the other hand, if you want to try out Bruce, you can give him a chance. He was one of my first villagers in NL and thought he was one of the better cranky villagers. Do what you feel is right for you!

 

[jobby47]

I think having two of them in different towns is fine, you should keep him.

 

[silver_shroud]

Thanks for all the responses, I appreciate it! I'm also glad to see that I'm not alone in my admiration of Roscoe.

 

[Rasha]

nope, not at all

 

[pippy1994]

Listen to your heart <3 XD

 

[DarkFox7]

If you truly love Roscoe and would feel regret and sadness by letting him go, then I say two Roscoes is just fine.

On the other hand, it's always good to try something new. If you feel that you need a change and that you want to experience Bruce, then you should get Bruce. You'll still have Roscoe either way! I agree that Bruce would fit a rock town PERFECTLY. I've had Bruce before in one of my old towns, he's pretty epic