Trying to decide between Erik or Hornsby!

[brockbrock]

If you want a more unique villager, go for Hornsby!

I think Erik is more popular and probably is on more islands than Hornsby.

 

[kiwikenobi]

I have Hornsby in my town, and he's adorable, so I'd say pick him.

 

[milraen]

Erik! Idk if it’s just me but I find Hornsby a bit boring looking. And I found him three times in just one island hopping villager search so maybe I’m biased against him

 

[Blueskyy]

Hornsby is cuter. Erik is actually pretty boring.

 

[GumbyWench]

Both of them! But, Erik and Hornsby are two of my dream villagers and I want them both so much, so perhaps I'm not the right person to ask!

 

[AquaMarie]

I absolutely love Erik (more than Beau!), but the deer are pretty popular and more common. I think Hornsby is super cute too and would be more unique. I had Erik in NL, so I wanted a different lazy this time around. Hornsby was very high on my list of possibilities, but then I completely fell for Bones and decided to get him instead.

 

[Bioness]

I've had both, I couldn't get over Hornsby's interior house (dirt and literal trash). I would say go with Erik.