1.
Puddles ~ She's the first villager that I grew attached to; she has been with me since I first created my town and I don't plan on ever letting her to go. Her facial expressions, the sound she makes when she's talking, and the peppy talk of hers ~ almost always makes me smile and sometimes cheers me up when I'm feeling down.
1.
Punchy ~ He's tied for first with Puddles; he too has been with me since I first created my town. Even though cats are my favorite animals, it took me a little longer to develop some sort of an opinion on him, which eventually became a strong attachment.

Also, he looks almost like a friend of mine's cat, who I'm BFF with

. Now, that I am strongly attached to him, I consider him one of the best ~ if not the best looking of all the cat villagers; I never want him to leave either. He and Puddles are always looking out for me and I really love them both equally for that. <3
2.
Kiki ~ I first met her while I was visiting someone's Dream Address, and the minute I talked to her, I knew I wanted to have her in my town. Before I talked to her, I thought she was kinda ugly and her nose looked like it was squished, but now, I think her "squished" nose is what makes her so adorable looking. Gladys had been my first normal (Kiki is my second) and while I liked her at first, I ended up getting tired of the normal villager talk. With Kiki in my town, however, while I do get irritated with her claims of having dreams about items that are in my pockets, or needing something that I had in my possession to paint a picture of or study; I actually don't mind the talk and think she's very sweet even though she said the same things as Gladys did (I talk to Kiki much more than I did with Gladys). Thank you Maruchan for selling me this sweetheart! <3 That was my first "villager purchase" and best decision I made in game ever, probably.

.
3.
Ankha: The snooty personality is my least favorite personality, so, Ankha is my favorite primarily if not solely because of her appearance. I love history and culture; my favorite culture to learn about is Middle Eastern, thus, is why I was quickly drawn to Ankha's unique appearance.
4. Rosie ~ The little tuft of hair on her head is so cute; I'm still heartbroken that I lost her by being careless while trying to figure out the camper reset trick. While I hadn't had her long enough to be attached to her as I am with Puddles (the peppy talk from her had less of an emotional "impact" on me as it did when Puddles said the same exact thing), I still thought she was a sweetheart and never wanted her to leave. The derpy facial expression and her color were what drew me to her.
5. Merry ~ I was torn between deciding between Felicity, Merry, and Rosie when it came down to deciding who my second peppy would be. I'd have loved to have them all (and Dotty too), but that would be too many peppies for me as much as I love the peppy villagers; I wanted my town to be diverse and interesting. :] Since I lost Rosie, I decided to adopt Merry at the very last minute when she was in boxes in a cycling town. She has such cute eyes and I love the little set of bangs she has. ^^
6. Pudge ~ I don't know what to say other than this picture is what made me fall in love with his cuteness
.
7. Roscoe ~ He's the only horse villager that I like in the game. Just looking a picture of him makes me feel a little intimidated of of him, but at the same time; that's what I like about him!
8. Gaston ~ Even though I didn't think much of him when I first created my town, over time I grew attached to him and now, I can't imagine him not being in my town. That old grouch earned a special place in my heart.

While I think there are cuter or better looking cranky villagers (and cuter bunnies/rabbits), I really do like his design. :]
I'll update this list later in a new post; I could only think of 8 ><