Tier 4's and 5's that grew on you

[LoonieToonies]

What undesired villager ended up growing on you? Mine is Astrid. She was camping in my cycle town and I instantly fell in love with her! I like how compared to most snooties, she looks for angry then snobby and doesn't have a ton if makeup. She's a cool gal.

 

[Raffy]

Freckles was a starter in my Wild World adventure and I fell in love with her and my obsession with ducks helped
I still have that copy of Wild World but I'm afraid to check because she probably moved out or something

 

[Snowfell]

I was campsite resetting in my old town and Marcel showed up like 4 times, after that I looked him up and saw that we have the same birthday so I had to invite him in. I wasn't sure at first because he's kinda odd looking but now he's one of my favourite villagers!

 

[sushiornot]

Velma was a starter in my New Leaf town and she was meh at first and then I started talking to her and now she is my favorite villager.

 

[BronzeElf]

Eloise. She pretty much forced herself on me. She was in my main Wild World game, I reset, she was there again. (2 times in Wild World). Then, she was in my City Folk main game. (1 time in CF) Then she was of my main villagers in New leaf. (1 time in NL)
5 times total. If she asks to leave I might let her go though.

 

[PlasmaPower]

Drift. He kept following me every town I created. I kept sending him off until one day, I decided to just let him in my current town.

 

[Elephantmarshmallow]

Dizzy! He was in my campsite and I thought he was cute so I invites him to move in and he did he's super cute and makes me laugh because of how random and crazy he is

 

[Millefeui]

I don't really judge villagers based on tiers, but since this is the purpose of the thread, then Walt.

 

[kikiiii]

shari is so darling & i wonder why she's such a low tier sometimes

 

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

Mostly Pecan.

 

[kayleee]

Peaches <3

 

[MOON TRIPS]

I also do not judge based on tiers. I'm not a big fan of most popular villagers, anyway. I have weird taste.
but there are many. Coach, Walt, Deena, Tex, Ricky, Puddles, Dotty
I also just love Egbert and Stinky

 

[Meliodas]

Hopper. He moved into my town after someone gave me him. He's a tier 4, and I just remember him from the Animal Crossing movie, so I wanted him. However, I didn't actually particularly like him. However, as I continued to talk to him and celebrated his birthday a lot, then he grew on me. Now he's one of my favorite villagers.

 

[n0bo]

Nan the Normal goat, I had her in WW and was devastated when I lost my copy..thankfully I got her back in NL

 

[Fighter_Kibbeh]

(post deleted)

 

[MetaTriforce]

Axel. He was a starter for my and my brother in our town in the original AC, and we ended up liking him a lot and we thought he was really funny. Then, lo and behold, he was one of my starters in New Leaf and I haven't let him move out. It's more nostalgia than anything else.

 

[Mints]

OMG I feel in love with Pierce, he was actually one of my starters. We grew very close together and he was actually my first (virtual) kiss. I remembered when he said "Hey Lulu, do you know how close we are?" and i was like "How much?" and then he screamed all caps "FIRST KISSES TASTE LIKE PEARS" im pretty sure we kissed. IM POSITIVE we did, ah I remember it like yesterday. But then he moved away....

- - - Post Merge - - -

Did I mention that me and Lucha hooked up after Pierce left? He called me his muffin... lol ok bye

 

[Clytemnestral]

I think Mint is a tier 4 or 5. She is my absolute favourite <3

 

[Lualdara]

Sparro, Elvis and Doc! I have them in Karmina and absolutely love them. Sparro especially has a great design imo and I love Doc's house (it's a classroom!)

 

[Skyfall]

All the goats, to be honest. I love Nan, Pashmina and Kidd. Kidd especially, I love him.