I started with Cherry and Scoot.
Neither of them were on my wishlist, but most certainly neither of them were on my least wanted either.
The next three to move in were Zucker, Bertha and Cheri. Zucker was on the first NMT island I visited and I didn't know how villagers moving in worked and desperately wanted more villagers, so I invited him. He really wasn't what I was looking for, but I'm glad I picked him because he has grown on me and is incredibly cute (I like to compare him to Snom from Pokemon. At first you're like "What in the world are you?" and then the cuteness hits you like a brick). Bertha was the same situation, a villager I moved in because I didn't know how things worked. Cheri was a random move-in.
The rest: My campsite villager was Hippeaux. Ugh! After getting him, I began grabbing every remotely good looking villager I could find on the NMT islands so RNG wouldn't make me regret it and give me another Hippeaux (although Cheri is cute and was also picked by RNG, the mind wanders toward the negative and thinks only of Hippeaux LOL).
That's how I ended up with a lopsided village with no Snooty or Cranky villagers. =( First villager I picked from the NMT was Bea. She was cute. Then I ran into Aurora, not recognizing that she was the same personality as Bea AND Bertha, I picked her because she was one of my favorites since the GCN days. Next one I picked was Jay. My town is named Lawrence, after the town where the University of Kansas resides. There was no way in the world I could pass up a red and blue bird named Jay for my Lawrence town. Sue me. Now with THREE normals and TWO jocks, I was determined to pick a Snooty or Cranky villager from my top favorites with NMTs... Until the very first island I went to, there was Beau. The same personality type as Zucker, but... Beau. He has the same name as a dog I loved so much that passed away years ago, and Beau is just adorable. I almost thought "No, I must find a Snooty/Cranky" but... I couldn't pass up Beau, and I wouldn't change my mind on that. Beau is never leaving from my town.
Dream Villagers:
First the ones from the personality types I need in my town:
Snooty: Cleo, Purrl, Annalise, Whitney, Vivian, Freya
Cranky: Fang, Wolfgang, Chief
Otherwise, Reneigh, Audie, Colton, Julian