• The results of the egg decorating contest have been announced! Everyone's designs were amazing! Congratulations to our winners!

The Villager Advisory Thread

i can't decide who to have as my other snooty in my second town. i visited a dream town and fell for whitney, though i had already decided on having willow as my second snooty. i wanted a mostly bunny/sheep town, but now it's mostly wolves lol i'm not sure if four wolves would be too much of if freya and whitney together would be too much, since they're the same personality ; w ;
 
Bonbon or Penelope?
Penelope most definitely uwu
i can't decide who to have as my other snooty in my second town. i visited a dream town and fell for whitney, though i had already decided on having willow as my second snooty. i wanted a mostly bunny/sheep town, but now it's mostly wolves lol i'm not sure if four wolves would be too much of if freya and whitney together would be too much, since they're the same personality ; w ;
If you really like Whitney, go for her ! However if you doubt you'd enjoy having 4 wolves with their floppy talking animation just go for willow. She's a pretty rad lady herself & sheep are the best
 
Bonbon or Penelope?

Penelope

- - - Post Merge - - -

i can't decide who to have as my other snooty in my second town. i visited a dream town and fell for whitney, though i had already decided on having willow as my second snooty. i wanted a mostly bunny/sheep town, but now it's mostly wolves lol i'm not sure if four wolves would be too much of if freya and whitney together would be too much, since they're the same personality ; w ;

Four wolves is definitely not too much :) get who you like best!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Bam: Yay or nay?
I don't absolutely LOVE him or anything, but I want to know whether or not I should keep him in my town. What's your experience with him? Do I sell/let him leave after getting his picture, or do I keep him for life?

If you don't like him,don't keep him. Get the pic and move on :o
 
I'm considering replacing Midge with Mitzi... I love both about equally, who would you choose? I thinking if I'm even thinking about getting Midge I must not like her that much, but IDK. Mitzi is cool, but I already have two cat dreamies, with the four sheep I have the town would get redundant fast.
 
Mint or Kitty?

Personally I like Mint better.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm considering replacing Midge with Mitzi... I love both about equally, who would you choose? I thinking if I'm even thinking about getting Midge I must not like her that much, but IDK. Mitzi is cool, but I already have two cat dreamies, with the four sheep I have the town would get redundant fast.

Aww, both Mitzi and Midge are cute :c if you're thinking about replacing her though, you're probably right -- you don't like her enough. Midge is more colorful and happy-ish though ^^
About the villager species thing, the dialogue will remain different as long as the personalities differ, so I don't think that's a huge problem. Many people have one-species towns and it's perfectly fine :) just depends if you want diversity or not I guess.
 
I don't know whether I should get Freya or Willow as a snooty. I was planning on getting Willow, but while I was plot resetting Freya's plot showed up and I impulsively decided to go with her. She's in my second town so I'd still have to move her over to my main town if I decided to keep her. I don't really like the wolf villagers, but I like her colors and her house looks nice, and when I talked to her after she moved in I liked her enough. I'm also planning on moving Frita over to my main town so I'll already have one sheep villager.

I'm just afraid I'll end up not liking Freya once I get her into my main town since I don't like the wolf villagers much, and I don't have enough time to get to know her very well in my second town because I'm still trying to get a lot of villagers for myself and a couple of other people.
 
I don't know whether I should get Freya or Willow as a snooty. I was planning on getting Willow, but while I was plot resetting Freya's plot showed up and I impulsively decided to go with her. She's in my second town so I'd still have to move her over to my main town if I decided to keep her. I don't really like the wolf villagers, but I like her colors and her house looks nice, and when I talked to her after she moved in I liked her enough. I'm also planning on moving Frita over to my main town so I'll already have one sheep villager.

I'm just afraid I'll end up not liking Freya once I get her into my main town since I don't like the wolf villagers much, and I don't have enough time to get to know her very well in my second town because I'm still trying to get a lot of villagers for myself and a couple of other people.
i don't much care for wolf villagers, myself (despite having three in my town, currently), but freya was the first wolf i ever liked, along with skye. her and skye are both different from the others, i think, with their different colored fur and girlish tendencies, that they don't bother me at all. freya is really awesome, i can definitely vouch for that, and i haven't gotten tired of her yet, despite how i feel about most wolves ^^ willow is great too. i'm stuck between her and another girl wolf, sigh.

also thanks @Dinomates and @Karen for the advice c: tbh, i'll probably just stick with whoever i get a hold of first, since that's how i've been doing with most of my villagers, aha.
 
Last edited:
I don't know whether I should get Freya or Willow as a snooty. I was planning on getting Willow, but while I was plot resetting Freya's plot showed up and I impulsively decided to go with her. She's in my second town so I'd still have to move her over to my main town if I decided to keep her. I don't really like the wolf villagers, but I like her colors and her house looks nice, and when I talked to her after she moved in I liked her enough. I'm also planning on moving Frita over to my main town so I'll already have one sheep villager.

I'm just afraid I'll end up not liking Freya once I get her into my main town since I don't like the wolf villagers much, and I don't have enough time to get to know her very well in my second town because I'm still trying to get a lot of villagers for myself and a couple of other people.

By the sounds of it, get Willow. No point getting someone you don't like, even if it's more convenient :c
 
I got Beau as one of my starter 5, should I keep him or give him away?

Do you think you might like him? If you don't want him at all then I'd say give him away, but if there's any chance you might want him you should hang onto him for a bit to see how you feel. I was unsure about Beau at first and almost let him go a couple of times, but eventually I fell in love with him and I'm so glad I hung onto him.

@jinyoung and @Karen, Thanks for the advice! I got a chance to talk to Freya a bit more and I do like her more than the other wolves, so I think I'm going to move her into my main town when she asks. I'll still get Willow in my second town to see how I feel about her though.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top