The Mystery about the birthday wish

[DJStarstryker]

I've seen people claim they got PWPs this way. I tried it. It didn't work for a PWP. I requested the police station as my birthday wish and it took over a month after that before I finally got it. I think it's just a coincidence if you get something not long after the wish.

 

[mistakenolive]

Wait, how does this even work?

On your birthday, right as you come out your door, a villager invites you/kidnaps you to their house, which is decorated and has a cake on the table. When you interact with it, the villager asks you to make a wish, which you type in. Then you blow out the candles (literally, you blow on the 3DS microphone). Then they ask you what you wished for, and you can choose to tell them or not.

Man, I wished for "more happy birthdays". Though I think I prefer that wish coming true than any dreamies

 

[Pickles]

I wished for "Scorpion" hoping it would make them more common in my town, but NOPE. LOL And they ask me all the time about it. I wish they could give me one! Now I have to wait until September and try for a dreamie, I guess I'll forget about this by then. lol

 

[Viva Xocolatl]

So you just type the name right? no any extra words? I'll try it, my birthday is soon.

 

[Ida]

I only typed Beaus name evening got him ^_^

 

[chainosaur]

I wished for Mitzi and Julian, but Mitzi I got in a trade so I doubt that's got anything to do with the birthday wish. I haven't seen Julian so... I'm banking on "coincidence".

I made this wish with my mule back in November, meh. My actual birthday is in June, and I wished for the Rococo set way back then.

 

[iPrinny]

If I have any space on my birthday I'll give this a try! It's on the 19th |D If I don't have any though I may not..no use disappointing myself when someone I want shows up in my camp and I can't take them xD;

 

[Steve Canyon]

So I didnt really understand what the wishing did. Does the game really try to give you items, projects, or villagers named in your wish? Or does anybody actually know? My birthday was in August and I wished for goodwill towards men. **** that I guess I wasted mine, I shoulda wished for stuff!

 

[Ida]

I think there is no confirmed fact about it and thats why it is ? mystery and why i started this thread ^_^ i wasted My main caracters wish the 29th november "wished for love and friendship" but when My alt village caracter had his birthday 12th december (yes thats the TT guy) i remembered the rumor and tried it out. It worked for me but as you Can see it looks like it works for some and dont work for others so i asume its still a mystery then?

 

[Dark]

wish i knew about this, I wished for bells :/

 

[Bear_Crossing]

When my birthday rolls around, 29th, I think I might wish for Dizzy or Zucker if my town has 9.

 

[itzafennecfox]

Sounds interesting, maybe I'll try it. I've always wondered what the point of the birthday wish was, considering it never seems to do anything from what I can tell. Maybe this is it.

 

[gingerbread]

Wished for Fauna, nothing has so far happened.

 

[rosiekitty405]

Well excuse me while I go make another character and try this.
If this is true people can get their dreamies so quick. Just keep making new characters
And having their birthday the next day time traveling. Dang it. I hope this doesn't cause
An uproar if it's true.

Edit: oh yeah. If its not true I honestly think they shouldn't make it work
In any future games because we know many would abuse the power of it.
Like if bells worked like if you wished for bells and you got like 100k people would abuse that.
They'd abuse it for dreamies,rare items,etc. So I honestly don't want that to happen.
So far with villagers though I don't mind but just as long bells don't come into
Play with this I'm fine with it.

 

[iPrinny]

If I have any space on my birthday I'll give this a try! It's on the 19th |D If I don't have any though I may not..no use disappointing myself when someone I want shows up in my camp and I can't take them xD;

I don't usually dredge up old topics but I wanted to tag onto my response in here.
I didn't have any space on my birthday and still don't, but I wished for "Ribbot" anyway. My villagers haven't said a word about it until yesterday when Lolly mentioned that she heard about it. She said what it was and that she thought it would come true soon. Someone here had mentioned their villagers asked about it constantly, but mine haven't...

Point being the game has kept track of my wish enough to bring it back up, and even note that it hasn't come true yet. I thought it was really interesting. I really think there IS something to the birthday wish, and I'm waiting to see what happens when I have an open spot. I'm willing to bet Ribbot will be in an igloo. If anyone cares I'll update if/when I get space, but at the rate things are going it could be a really long time(like it's already been)...

 

[Bear_Crossing]

The birthday wish is crap. I wished for Diana and nothing.
In fact, I got the worst post birthday gift, Sylvia's fricking house plot.
After that, I actually wished that Diana wouldn't show up so I was disappointed.

 

[Grunge]

im going to try wishing for drago. since he is you know ... a dragon. okay an alligator but ... those wings .... DRAGON. and he's green!

 

[Lion-Lhasa]

Although my birthday's not until April, I will be wishing for a villager. Got plenty of time to decide which one..
It'll be quite interesting to see if it comes true.

iPrinny, I find it very interesting that the game has remembered your wish and even brought it up again. Hopefully they're just waiting for space in your town.

 

[Gummysaur]

ugh I wish I knew about this! nooby me literally just typed "I wish for all my dreamies" and now my villagers wont shut up about it, including my dreamies that I managed to get xD

 

[MeghanNewLeaf]

That sounds awesome! My birthday isn't for a long time, but I'll definitely try to get a Dreamie!