I love Pietro, I have him in my town so I might be biased though... but he is such an adorable fluff of joy. Shep, O'Hare and Zell seem pretty rad as well but never had them.
Lopez was probably my favorite Smug in my town, but Marshal is the cutest I've had. I feel as though not many people really know Lopez though. But the deer are pretty awesome!
I like all my smugs, so it's hard to chose, and I'm sure I would like those I've never met.
I'm fond of Kyle, he's a wolf with the heavy lids - and I have an alt which has the same eyes (albeit not a popular choice for human characters) & they also live next door to one another - sort of brothers.
His house is a bit run down tho.
I have Quillson in the same town, I like the ducks, he's cute, green and & sort of mouldy. (well I have fun with greetings/phrases)
I guess I would chose a smug on their looks and also the look of their house, whatever fits in with your town.
Besides Shep, because dogs are simply amazing, I also love Pietro.
I?ve always had a soft spot for Pietro because he?s a rainbow sheep and I am super gay.
I really like Hans. My town is supposed to be located really far up north, so having a villager based on a yeti is very nice for that. Now that I actually have him in my town, I like him even more.